Submitted 3 weeks ago by Beep@lemmus.org to technology@lemmy.world
the fact that ministry of justice of any state, regardless of specific geopolitical problems going on at any given time, would just upload its data to any “cloud” no matter what state it is operated from, is mind blowing to me.
you would really expect some standards for such sensitive data.
Ditto. I would have expected most justice ministries to self-host or at least use domestic servers.
AWS and other US cloud hosts do have data centers in various “regions” (countries) around the world. Some countries have requirements that the servers are physically located there. And iirc, as I worked with some of this in the past, as an example some EU countries for their services required that only EU citizens had certain types of access to those systems. Ultimately they are still owned by US companies. But those companies try to accommodate their access requirements, in order to get their business. Not saying EU shouldn’t move away from US companies, but wanted to clarify some existing policies.
no matter what state it is operated from
Not disagreeing, but if Trump hadn’t won a second term there really wouldn’t be a dire reason to avoid the US. Sure they would be better of choosing a local or at least European provider, but most politicians (naively) didn’t see the current hostility coming.
but most politicians (naively) didn’t see the current hostility coming.
i don’t think that’s relevant. such sensitive data should be kept in-house and well guarded, not uploaded into public cloud.
Imagine being the person in the Finland Ministry of Justice who’s been railing on about this for years and constantly getting shit on by idiot managers who can’t install (or use) their own software. Watch it make the national news and then they decide to go ahead and use AWS anyway.
I’m pretty sure a lot of us are that person.
Some of us here think it’s no coincidence the move was considered just as a right wing government happens to be in power. Especially since there was no significant cost savings from the proposed move.
It was already unpopular, but the USA going full Putin now has the average Finn also seeing it as suspicious, instead of just the left wing.
i mean, reality has a slight left wing bias.
No government organization should ever be using foreign hosting, period, but using usa’s is an especially awful idea
Easier said than done for a country that size, but I always think it would be amazing if Finland could band together with a couple dozen or so other European countries to form some kind of cooperative Union that would allow the creation of this kind of project. I also imagine that if such a thing did exist and you were a part of it you’d have to be a complete fucking dickbasket to leave it but that’s neither here nor there.
Dickbaskets have an annoying habit of getting into positions of power.
Hosting with close allies isn’t a problem.
Within the EU, I still don’t care in which country the data is hosted
It’s still a problem. Never forget that today’s friend can be tomorrow’s enemy.
But it is relevant, see the french graphene os crackdown.
Good. Get American technology out. Follow Germany’s lead.
Halt it, US dependencies can and will be using against you in the future
All your data are belong to us.
American oligarchs will bribe the government to continue doing their bidding, even against nations that were once our allies.
Put your private citizens data on US servers?
Nah. More like giving your private citizens data to HS government.
That you even started to consider it in 2026 is bizarre, really
It’s a government thing. I’m not sure when they’ve started to consider alternatives, but that renewal process (as old systems are on EOL) has most likely been on the table for years.
I’m an American and work as a cloud infra engineer. Imagine a world where Amazon and Palantir sleep together. Don’t consider, just don’t do it. Keep your sovereignty.
Wow, if only there was some software originating in Finland they could use…
That’s not an alternative. In fact almost everything cloud already is Linux.
It’s almost like you don’t actually understand exactly what options they’re looking at. And you just feel like throwing Linux out for everything. Considering that a lot of AWS does actually run on Linux.
I think realistically right now everyone is putting brakes on till November elections. If Trump doesn’t go full hitler till election date and declares an empire, he’s likely done in Nov.
Oh no, no… Trust in America is gone forever, no matter who wins. Because American people have demonstrated (twice) that they can choose someone like Trump as a president. The world won’t be waiting anxiously for the next Trump. We’ll move on.
I wouldn’t say forever. But it will take a long time to rebuild.
What is unique to American people? I easily foresee the next Trump from any country.
Especially if they have the same bad voting system of “pick the the lesser evil”. Do that enough times and you can get worse than Trump.
Even if the electios are free in fair, I don’t think he’d be done in November.
The only way he’s “done” is if GOP loses every single last senate seat up for grabs. Every single one in Nebraska, Wyoming, Montana, Idaho, Kansas, Oklahoma, South Dakota, West Virginia, Florida, Texas, etc.
Hell, most analysts think that Democrats don’t have a realistic chance of even getting a simple senate majority, let alone a veto-proof one or even a filibuster proof one.
If they don’t then they cannot remove anyone from office, they cannot override vetos. Yes, they can decline to pass bills, but given their stance of ‘executive branch has supreme power’, they’ll just do illegal executive orders and ignore the courts unless the supreme court agrees with them. Trump is already declared immune from any and all crimes except by the Senate and has the ability to pardon any and all federal cases, and that’s assuming his own enforcement agencies even bother trying to punish anyone…
I’m sure the Democrats will select a top-tier candidate for us like Gavin Newsom in 2028. One of the most pressing issues in this country right now is there is a lot of hate against minority groups like billionaires and zionists, and a candidate like Newsom would work tirelessly to make sure these groups don’t have to live in fear.
I think he’s corporate funded. Do t want that guy.
Who is going to say nationalize seashores for all people to use, federal mandatory yearly vacations, universal healthcare - will get my vote.
Is Gavin saying that?
The oligarchs are all fascist Zionists with or without Trump. American tech can’t be trusted and the only real solution is public tech alternatives.
Bit late to the party, but good to see another country waking up to the realisation that the US cannot be trusted. Now if only my own country would realise that...
I’m dum founded why we are even considering overseas services, there is a literal datacenter boom going on right now. There are like many local, including massive google, hetzner providers.
AWS, or cloud in general, is an money extortion service in practice for very large customers.
“considering” … Guys. do any of you watch the news?
We’ve formed a committee
I hope Sweden and more Erupoean contries does the same
Is there a site listing what exactly European solutions are missing as alternative? It’s so weird that a continent with population, education and wealth of Europe struggles with… software? These are all solved problems and software development becomes easier by the day. Come on.
We only struggle with what we produce not being bought up by American giants.
Writing the software isn’t a problem. Having the company survive is.
Ericsson was doing great until it got swallowed up by globalization.
The one-two punch of the US and China shuttered a lot of viable global infotech companies.
It would be interesting to study those cases, to see exactly what failed. We’re not weak and should be able to survive in „globalization“ context. Anyway, now it’s (more obviously) a matter of security too.
I would assume this is more a Finland specific problem, AFAIK Slovakia for example has a private cloud for all government IT stuff.
Though that might be due to corruption in this state…
Europe struggles with agile, in my experience
Agile is just one possible way to organize things and many developers don’t even like it or think that it improves productivity.
They didn’t used to. England in particular had a leg up during the PC revolution. There are also a lot of really great game studios there in the 90s.
And to be fair there still are some, but they broke al lot of ground in the early days. I don’t know what happened; American enshittification possibly left a bad taste in a lot of folks mouths.
The studios are still there in a lot of cases, but they are part of EA or other giants.
Finland already has very good datacenter companies, as one would expect…
I moved my VPS to a finnish company almost 10 years ago before data sovereignty was cool
Not even starting seems like the best way to deal with this halting problem
I would think that one of these European datacenters could manage to raise a control plane providing cheap load balancers and stand up some file/data clusters. It can’t be THAT hard to compete with amazon
I heard Japan is starting to get big in the cloud sector.
Lol
They don’t exactly have an excess of land to build datacenters
How so?
If they don’t want Putin nosing in they should forego it
Goodlucksil@lemmy.dbzer0.com 3 weeks ago
Only considering?! Nevertheless good enough.
vpol@feddit.uk 3 weeks ago
In order to halt they have to consider it first. There is some process required.
mumblerfish@lemmy.world 3 weeks ago
Then migration will take years if they already are established in US cloud services
RobotToaster@mander.xyz 3 weeks ago
That was my first reaction, but anyone who’s been anywhere near the civil service knows it will take 16 meetings just to decide to have a meeting about it. The fact they’ve even considered it within a year means this must be high priority.
DreamlandLividity@lemmy.world 2 weeks ago
I think rather than good enough, it is a good start.