Submitted 3 weeks ago by PugJesus@piefed.social to historymemes@piefed.social
https://media.piefed.social/posts/16/QX/16QXxOVPXcw6N8a.jpg
It is actually fairly irritating to me when people do this. It’s not a proper noun. It’s honestly wild to completely change your accent for the pronunciation of a single word in your sentence.
If you had a trans-atlantic accent, you wouldn’t suddenly roll your rs when pronouncing “burrito”, or do an impression of the Japanese when saying “sashimi”. If you did, it would probably sound disrespectful af.
So why does everyone do it with “croissant” and act like it’s totally normal?
I think people have made the point with specific references like “coup d’etat” and “faux pas”. I think the general answer is that language standards are fluid and common usage tends to become standard over time. The word “croissant” might be in a transition period depending on personal experience. I’ve always heard it in pronounced in the French or at least French-ish way, so to me “croy-sant” sounds kind of hillbilly. I grew up with Pillsbury Crescent Rolls.
Exactly! Rapidly changing accent for single words leads to poor understanding, which is the whole point of speech.
A loanword is not a word randomly spoken in another language, it’s a word taken from one language into another, which often involves a change in pronunciation.
If you dont acknowledge that, you’d have to acknowledge that the entire French language is just poorly pronounced Latin, which is insane.
“Burrito” is a Spanish word for a little donkey, but it’s also an English word for a food item, and they are not typically pronounced the same. Someone fluent in both languages will pronounce them differently depending on which language they are speaking.
zaph@sh.itjust.works 3 weeks ago I doubt you pronounce tortilla “tour-till-uh” or Coup d’état “coop-dee-tat.” Sometimes we change the pronunciation and sometimes we don’t.
How do you pronounce jalapeño?
Duh… jappaleeno!
IDK what “trans-atlantic” means for you, nor what you mean by putting on an accent or impression, but I’m German and I made it a habit to try to pronounce foreign words closer to their native language. I do roll rs in burrito, for instance. It’s not a big change. Croissant is a given since everyone here pronounces it fairly French anyway. I don’t know how Sashimi is pronounced, but if I had regular encounters with the word, I’d probably learn.
“Trans-atlantic” is a forced/learned accent that used to be more popular ~100 years ago. It was basically meant to represent people that were born in the US, but educated in the UK (or vice versa). Essentially, it was supposed to signify that you were wealthy enough to have connections on both sides of the Atlantic.
People intentionally learned to speak that way, though, and it became common on radio broadcasts (so you could also hear it referred to as an “old-timey announcer voice” or something similar).
teft@piefed.social 3 weeks ago Probably because english has a bunch of french words we do this for because of our legacy with courtly french. Entree is another example.
Can someone please tell me how Americans, or whoever this meme is about, pronounce croissant? Because I only know the french pronunciation and can not imagine another one.
Generally, in the US, it’s pronounced as cres-AHNT. It has a clear R sound, the T at the end involves moving your tongue toward the T position, but the word ends without a clear T sound (as opposed to the French pronunciation, where the R becomes a W and the word ends on the N sound, with the T completely omitted.)
Kolanaki@pawb.social 3 weeks ago Me: “I’ll have a crescent, please.”
teft@piefed.social 3 weeks ago The t is silent. The end sound is a nasal n so more like kwah–sahn with the final n being very nasal and soft.
I actually find the french r to be super difficult though. Way the hell back in the throat where letters aren’t supposed to be formed.
There is absolutely no way to spell French phonetically, so we should all just give it up now
teft@piefed.social 3 weeks ago And just when you think you understand how to spell in french they throw some other weird rule at you.
It’s because your mouth isn’t soft enough. French requires you to release the tension in your mouth and tongue, it’s weird but it really works
It’s especially hard because the harder you try, the more tense your mouth is, so you are less likely to do it.
It is pronounced croissant actually
No no no no no.
It’s croissant.
Same in parts of germany. Though we also have tongue-r regions so you can choose
darklamer@feddit.org 3 weeks ago WTF is ‘cwah-sont’!?
darklamer@feddit.org 3 weeks ago I fail to see the connection to ‘cwah-sont’, apart from the first and last letter being the same, but if that was a sufficent criteria then one might as well write just anything, like ‘convalescent’.
A French pastry
darklamer@feddit.org 3 weeks ago Not that I would ever claim to know every French pastry, but I’m reasonably certain that there’s nothing in all of France or in the French language named ‘cwah-sont’.
Lumidaub@feddit.org 3 weeks ago [t]
… tch. Imbecile.
nightlily@leminal.space 3 weeks ago
Quaso