Proposal sails through, with one vocal opponent saying gay first cousins do not risk having a child with birth defects
Archived version: archive.ph/Ri2sc
Submitted 7 months ago by BrikoX@lemmy.zip to globalnews@lemmy.zip
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/apr/11/tennessee-marriage-ban-first-cousins
Proposal sails through, with one vocal opponent saying gay first cousins do not risk having a child with birth defects
Archived version: archive.ph/Ri2sc
I can’t see how two consenting adults wanting to marry is an issue. Sure, having biological kids born out of incest should be criminalized as that comes under child abuse (going ahead with a pregnancy where the probability of the child having to suffer a birth defect is very high.).
Let’s say I want to marry my first cousin. Both of us are 22 and 24. We are both adults. Why should society get to decide what we can and cannot do? If you say “love is love” and support this bill, you are a hypocrite.
I can’t tell if this is serious or not
I am being dead serious. Memes aside, we need to question the logic behind every single thing that we believe in. That is exactly what I am attempting to do. I would encourage you to do the same :)
This is Rudy Guliannis alt account
So, accidental pregnancy between consenting adults that took precautions occurs. Is the state requiring a choice between abortion or jail? Just for the woman, or for both? What if the couple disagree on abortion? Still jail for both, or just one?
Hmm, interesting problem where I don’t exactly have a good answer. But I would still support some form of criminalisation. If I fed my 3 year old cocaine while knowing it was cocaine, should I not be jailed for abuse? Is this situation not similar?
I tend to agree. There’s only minor biological issues with marrying a cousin, around a 3% increase in birth defects if my quick google is correct. It’s only a cascading problem like people expect when it happens over and over in the same family tree… (or should I say family stick?)
having biological kids born out of incest should be criminalized as that comes under child abuse
It’s the same as any other situation where a couple has known genetic traits that make birth defects much more likely. Why should it be criminalized if the parents are related, but not when the parents are unrelated, even though the outcome for the child is the same?
I’m not very confident in answering this, but this is my answer- Knowing that ur kid will have genetic defects is very easy if you know that your partner is your sibling, no? To know the other genetic traits, you would have to consciously conduct genetic tests n stuff. But not so much for incest.
Welcome to the 20th century
You do know it’s legal in many other states? Including loads of liberal states? Or were you just taking a dig on Tennessee?
I just want to say that I love the gay first cousins argument. It makes sense in a fucked up way, I guess you could make a bill forcing first cousins to be sterilized if they want to marry and get the same end result.
Better late than never
A couple cousin fuckers were mad about this, apparently.
HonkTonkWoman@lemm.ee 7 months ago
I love how the pic for the article is, presumably, a lesbian couple…
Yep, all those hot & steamy incestuous lesbians in Tennessee are about to riot.
Breezy@lemmy.world 7 months ago
Well the bill originally had an exception for all the supposed lesbien cousins. The governor or someone got to get all upset and strike part of the bill. Then go on talk about how bad the gays cousins were for wanting the exception.
Anyolduser@lemmynsfw.com 7 months ago
I think I saw a documentary film about one of those couples.