mrmaplebar
@mrmaplebar@fedia.io
- Comment on [Rec] Anime with several consecutive or a high percentage of masterpiece episodes. 8 hours ago:
- Samurai Champloo, Directed by Shinichiro Watanabe of Cowboy Bebop fame. Personally I don't feel that there's a bad episode in the whole show. Great soundtrack by a bunch of Japanese hip hop artists, including Nujabes who sadly is no longer with us.
- FLCL, Directed by Kazuya Tsurumaki, and it's an iconic and wild 6-episode masterpiece. Amazing story, animation and soundtrack by The Pillows. (Ignore everything after the original 6 episode show)
- Gunbuster & Diebuster two other 6 episode OVA by Gainax. Gunbuster was directed by Hideaki Anno of Evangelion, and Diebuster was done by Anno's protege, Kazuya Tsurumaki of FLCL. These two female "guts and hard work" mecha shows share similar themes, but are mostly stand-alone shows. However, I highly recommend watching Gunbuster first, as it makes Diebuster hit even harder.
- Kaiba this show is kind of a hidden gem. Directed by Masaaki Yuasa of Mind Game and Ping Pong the Animation, this unique and cutesy show is all about living in a post-humanist world where people can switch bodies and access memories. Despite its cute and childlike artstyle, this show has some pretty dark and adult themes, and it respects your intelligence with interesting non-linear storytelling.
- Comment on Steam's AI disclosures are akin to "forcing developers to list their voting history", says man who must hate seeing eggs virtue signal that they're free-range 3 weeks ago:
There's the no AI camp that irrationally hates anything that even sounds like AI use. There's the fanatic camp that thinks AGI is basically here and everything will be AI. Then there's those that recognize AI is a useful tool, and it's not going away.
Hmm... You're kind of showing your hand here, aren't you?
The no AI ever group is large and very vocal. It's probably a plurality and maybe a majority of people. Until that group shrinks there won't be any meaningful dialog about acceptable AI usage.
I don't think the arguments that "AI is a useful tool" and "it's not going away" are strong or convincing enough to simply shrug away the real social, technological, cultural, ethical, economic, environmental and legal issues that are at the heart of the AI industry today. Part of having a rational dialog about AI is not just jumping on the hype train, but also acknowledging the new problems and challenges that come with it.
If anything, like all emerging technologies, those arguments really only highlight our social responsibility to question the uses and consider the implications of AI even more. After all, tools can be used for good or bad. And if we're going to have to live with the existence of AI, then we will certainly need reasonable laws and regulations in place to protect people from misuse of those tools, right?
So, if you're wondering why the anti-AI group is large and growing, part of that is probably because "resistance is futile" is not a compelling reason to get on board with a grossly unprofitable technology that is being shoehorned into everything while stealing from artists and threatening the livelihoods of workers. I don't like seeing working people exploited for the short term stock market gains of a handful of big tech companies. I think it's wrong, and it's not something I want to support as long as I have the choice.
But anyway, I'm more than happy to have a meaningful dialog about AI, and I don't see why we can't, because I don't think anything I've said is "irrational" or off-base at all.
- Comment on Steam's AI disclosures are akin to "forcing developers to list their voting history", says man who must hate seeing eggs virtue signal that they're free-range 3 weeks ago:
But that's my point, not everyone agrees with that assessment.
Well people can't even agree on who won the last election or even if the world is round, so I can only speak to my point of view on things.
The problem is there's things like code completers, that predate AI, and no one ever had a problem with those even though presumably they were also taking work from other people. So how much AI can be used before AI becomes unacceptable. You can set the bar at zero, but then you start getting problems of defining what even constitutes AI.
To me it's very clear that the heart of the problem is not in "AI" or "machine learning" itself, but the way that almost all of the large AI models have been trained on work which has been scraped from other people without even so much as basic consent--to say little about licenses or payment. Consent is pretty massively important factor here. After all, I think most of us can agree on the fact that consent is the difference between "borrowing" and "theft", the difference between "sex" and "rape", and the difference between "employment" and "slavery".
Is it possible to make an ethical AI?
Of course it is. But I feel that it would require an AI that was developed in a non-exploitative way, trained on data that has been legitimately acquired, licensed, public domain, cc-0, or otherwise "fair use". Almost nobody is doing that, to my knowledge. Maybe someone in the open source world is working on it, and if so, kudos to them, but certainly none of the big AI corporations are.
As for where we draw the line of what is or isn't OK, in the US at least, "fair use" law is the mechanism that we have historically used to determine which particular unauthorized uses of other people's copyrighted work are OK. And there are many factors that are considered for determining whether some kind of use is or isn't fair.
So I agree there is a nuanced discussion to be had, but most of the time we are not talking about simple, small code completion tasks (like asking your IDE to create an empty definition of a method in the .cpp file or whatever). We are generally talking about people using large model AI systems to generate the actual "business logic" of a program, seemingly out of thin air (as long as you pay no attention to the man behind the curtain).
Part of having a real discussion is opening our eyes to the darker side of the AI industry and acknowledging the fact that the intellectual labor of working people and the creative class are being exploited at a truly unprecedented scale.
At any rate, I'm more than happy to have the conversation, even if I don't have infinite time to dedicate to it.
- Comment on Steam's AI disclosures are akin to "forcing developers to list their voting history", says man who must hate seeing eggs virtue signal that they're free-range 3 weeks ago:
Whether it's art or code is basically a difference without a distinction to me personally. I'm not sure what makes it different.
Like, in my view, if you're using a generative AI model that was trained without license, compensation or even so much as basic consent from the people who created the original training data, then I feel that is an unpaid exploitation of other people's intellectual labor. You are taking advantage of someone else's work, and in most cases doing so regardless of any kinds of copyright, license, or other agreement. And, considering a former top AI executive at Microsoft called what they were doing "the largest theft of labor in human history", I think I'm not alone in looking at it that was.
As a person, I've always been something of a "jack of all trades"--I like making art and playing music, but I also like computers, programming, FOSS and game dev. I'd be lying to you if I sad that I wasn't pretty sad and disappointed to be living through a time of mass fraudulence and exploitation, when human skills and creativity are instantly punished by theft and exploitation on an unprecedented scale, by those with the most money and compute power in the name of short term profit and "the ends justify the means" thinking.
- Comment on Steam's AI disclosures are akin to "forcing developers to list their voting history", says man who must hate seeing eggs virtue signal that they're free-range 3 weeks ago:
As someone who has an ethical problem with how most generative AI has been trained on the exploited labor of other people, I do feel like I have a right to know who is and isn't leveraging it.
- Age of Empires studio World's Edge reportedly lose nearly half their staff and a new game project in mass Xbox layoffswww.rockpapershotgun.com ↗Submitted 1 month ago to rts@fedia.io | 0 comments
- Submitted 1 month ago to rts@fedia.io | 0 comments
- Comment on Any self-hostable alternative to playit.gg for easily exposing local game servers to the public internet? 2 months ago:
I was hoping to have servers be more public, so visible on the master server list and able to be joined by random people. (I'm a glutton for punishment I guess. lol)
- Submitted 2 months ago to selfhosted@lemmy.world | 15 comments
- Submitted 2 months ago to selfhosted@lemmy.world | 5 comments