mrmaplebar
@mrmaplebar@fedia.io
- Comment on [Discussion] New ‘Ghost In The Shell’ Anime Is Gloriously Goofy And Very Faithful To The Manga 1 week ago:
The first episode of the new series is basically a panel-for-shot adaptation of the manga in both story and style. It's definitely a lot more cartoony than the previous anime films and series.
- Comment on [Episode] THE GHOST IN THE SHELL • Koukaku Kidoutai: THE GHOST IN THE SHELL - Episode 1 discussion 1 week ago:
Fair enough, I suppose.
I have my issues with it, and I basically had to watch it twice due to the very fast pacing and difficult dialogue/subtitles. But as a fan of these characters and this world, I did enjoy it and I'm glad to be seeing it.
For better or worse, the intent here seems to be to make a faithful adaptation of the iconic Shirow Masamune manga, both in terms of storytelling and stylization. Whether you think that's a good goal or not really depends on how you feel about the manga, and whether it's worth adapting in such a direct way. But that's clearly what Science Saru is trying to do, and it hasn't been done before with this manga.
As a fan of the Masamune's manga, Oshii's films, and Kamiyama's SAC series (at least SAC, 2nd gig, and SSS), I see these all being threads of the tapestry that is Ghost in the Shell. Very different in style and substance, but all of them work together to create an interesting world and a set of great characters exploring interesting themes where humanity and technology coverage. I didn't think one detracts from the others.
In that sense I disagree that this is "shitting all over something that you like", and it's probably more accurate to say that it's being overly faithful to a manga that you don't care for.
- Comment on [Episode] THE GHOST IN THE SHELL • Koukaku Kidoutai: THE GHOST IN THE SHELL - Episode 1 discussion 2 weeks ago:
Why?
- Comment on Use of Japanese anime and manga for AI training is a "serious issue that undermines creators' rights," CODA warns tech companies 1 month ago:
If big tech corporations (the richest companies on Earth, by far, by the way) value these works enough to use them as part of their AI training datasets, then maybe, just maybe, they should value the creators enough to pay them what they are owed for the rights to use the data.
Copyright law was made by those in power to protect the idea of intellectual property, but clearly they are willing to ignore their own rules at the first convenience.
- Comment on The way "self-checkout" has been pushed on us is nothing short of injustice 1 month ago:
Yep, exactly my experience at basically all the grocery stores near me.
Self-checkout used to be quick and easy, now it's just an exercise in patience and being treated like a crook.
- Comment on The way "self-checkout" has been pushed on us is nothing short of injustice 1 month ago:
I prefer self-checkout. I'm fast and I don't really like small talk.
What really sucks is that modern self-checkout requires so much babysitting and cashier assistance, because they assume everyone is a criminal. The supermarket has become the panopticon.