I mean, this doesn’t really change anything from a practical perspective. It just highlights that the verbage in the press release was alarmist.
It’s still a security concern that most users will be unaware of.
Submitted 3 weeks ago by megaman@discuss.tchncs.de to technology@lemmy.world
https://darkmentor.com/blog/esp32_non-backdoor/
I mean, this doesn’t really change anything from a practical perspective. It just highlights that the verbage in the press release was alarmist.
It’s still a security concern that most users will be unaware of.
Yes, in the sense that every device you own has these same commands
The alarmist of the original was that this was somehow unique to the esp32
If your device has Bluetooth, it has these commands
But but it’s Chinese and Chinese tech bad
Thanks. I was looking for an explanation like this
Potato, potato…
Whether we call them ‘undocumented commands’ or a ‘backdoor’, the affect is more or less the same; a series of high-level commands not listed within the specs, preventing systems engineers/designers from planning around vulnerabilities and their potential for malicious use.
In that case, every stack that you use is riddled with those and we are all hosed. And yet somehow your computer, your phone and the internet keep on working most of the time.
I tried to offer a gentler backgrounder on this HCI business: lemmy.ml/comment/17160273
The opcodes that actually jumped out at me more than the undocumented ones were the ones that erases the flash.
But the conclusion stands. None of this is a ‘backdoor’ unless you can secretly access it from the wireless side and nothing in the presentation points to that. If I had to guess, the opcodes are for QA and tuning on the manufacturing line.
SpaceNoodle@lemmy.world 3 weeks ago
Finally, some technical details that were sorely lacking from yesterday’s article.
Anyway, having direct unprivileged R/W access to platform memory is indeed a security hole, no matter the vendor.
pelya@lemmy.world 3 weeks ago
It is not. ESP32 is an embedded chip with less than one megabyte of RAM. It cannot run apps or load websites with any malicious code, it only runs the firmware that you flash on it, nothing else, and of course your firmware has full access to every chip feature. If your firmware has a security hole, it’s not the chip’s fault.
SpaceNoodle@lemmy.world 3 weeks ago
Try reading the article next time.