Unboxious

I love how every moment with Taira is an existential crisis.

Can’t say I’ve seen a ton of mystery anime, but ODDTAXI was really really good.

I was wondering how she was gonna get away this time with all the helicopters on her. It’s been an “okay” show so far; I look forward to its conclusion.

War is barely in this movie directly, but it does a great job with what it’s got.

and he’s immediately exposing the skillbook that he just purchased

It was crazy to me that he was openly carrying illicitly-obtained goods and talking loudly about using them at the beginning of the episode!

What a way to end the episode! I don’t think there could possibly be anything more encouraging Subaru could’ve said than simply calling her “Emilia-tan” again.

I love their chart!

Not the end credits song I was expecting!

Anyways, great show. This easily beat out Stand-Alone Complex as the best Ghost in the Shell adaptation in my eyes, and I loved Stand-Alone Complex.

I often see people assuming Fragrant Flower is shoujo, Kaguya-sama is either shounen or shoujo, Blue Box is shoujo, and Chainsaw Man is seinen.

The base assumptions seem to be “There’s a love story where we’ve gone two chapters in and the female lead hasn’t stripped yet??? Must be shoujo!” and “Wow that’s a lot of blood, must be seinen.”

Yeah but that’s not necessarily a bad thing. You probably wouldn’t want a shot-for-shot transcription going from manga to live-action.

I mean, there’s a >0 number of good live-action adaptations of animated shows. I’ve heard mainly good things about the Netflix One Piece show.

I cannot remember the title off the top of my head, but I remember reading about at least one manga that changed the magazine it was originally serialised in to reach a different market segment.

Vinland Saga did this. There are others, but that’s the one that comes to mind.

So, publishers know full well that it’s not just teenage boys reading shounen stories. There are actually more girls reading shounen than there are girls reading shoujo. For this reason a lot of stories that appeal to both end up being published as shounen, whereas stories that are more likely to only appeal to girls get published as shoujo. The same thing happens with seinen and josei; lots of adult women read seinen stuff, whereas it’s less common for adult men to read josei stuff. Seinen magazines have also been around for a lot longer than josei magazines, so sometimes if a mangaka wanted to publish something spicy in a shoujo magazine it would end up getting rejected and getting published in a seinen magazine instead if the publisher and the mangaka thought they could swing it.

This one I don’t have stats on, but I suspect there are more adults reading shounen/shoujo than there are kids/teens reading seinen/josei. The big shounen magazines are really big, so if the mangaka for a story like Frieren thinks their story appeals to everyone it makes sense to pitch it with the big shounen magazines first.

I always thought it was a description, but it just seems to be an origin

It’s both. It’s telling you “hey, if you’re a teenage boy you’re more likely to like this.” It’s also telling you that the writing is less likely to be difficult to read or understand. Once you’re familiar with what gets published for these demographics it tells you all sorts of things, really.

Shounen aren’t all about fights in the first place though. Sure some of them are, but as covered by other posts in this thread there are plenty of shounen romance series too.

The series had more focus on the Drama as opposed to mecha

Just FYI, that’s almost every Gundam series.

Apart from the ones you listed, here are a few anime that I’ve seen people get wrong lately:

• A Fragrant Flower Blooms With Dignity - shounen
• Kaguya-sama: Love is War - seinen
• Chainsaw Man - shounen

I think season 1 of Clevatess was better than season 1 of Sentenced to Be a Hero, but Clevatess fell off a little in season 2 imo and I only watched the first couple hours of Sentenced so maybe it got better than what I saw.

It absolutely does.

I mean, it’s aimed at teenagers not small children.

I agree with most of this, but the idea of a classic big three is something that only exists in your head. I’d argue Legend of the Galactic Heroes is better than any of those three, and it aired at about the same time.

Mirai and Belle were both pretty mediocre imo.

Perfect Blue wasn’t bad or anything, but it needs a “this movie is generally fucked up” content warning.

Tokyo Godfathers is probably the best Christmas movie in anime.

Summer Wars has kind of a nonsense plot but it’s such an accurate depiction of a family reunion that watching it makes me feel nostalgic anyways.

Last Monday someone from my Japanese conversation club lent me some volumes of What Do You Call This Trash? they pulled off a shelf at random in a bookstore in Japan. It was kinda crazy. The situation at the start of chapter 1 is that the main character’s older brother has broken up with his girlfriend. Knowing that the main character is into her, the older brother’s crazy ex asks him for help stalking his older brother in exchange for things like being given the chance to hold her hand. It’s an absolute mess - a bit like watching a trainwreck in real time, or perhaps “trash fire” would be the more appropriate term here. But you know what? I enjoyed both volumes of it. Would recommend to anyone looking for that specific kind of story.

Yes, though I feel like I unfortunately need to attach a warning: it’s really slow for the entire first half of the show. When it picks up it really picks up though!

You’re telling me that the manga that was serialized in Bessatsu Shounen Magazine isn’t a shounen?

Since you enjoyed Ghost in the Shell, I’d recommend giving the new The Ghost in the Shell TV show a try. It preserves the sometimes-goofy, sometimes-serious feeling of the original manga, and it’s quickly become my favorite adaptation of The Ghost in the Shell. Ghost in the Shell: Stand-Alone Complex is also quite good if you want just the serious feel, but I personally think the humor in the new one works really well. Crazy that a few decades ago the best new cyberpunk anime was Ghost in the Shell, and now in 2026 the best new cyberpunk anime is once again The Ghost in the Shell. I wonder if cyberpunk is just too close to reality to be enjoyable these days.

The writer of Fullmetal Alchemist also has a new anime based on her work coming out, called Daemons of the Shadow Realm. It’s another action-adventure thing, and I’ve been enjoying it quite a lot.

Honestly there’s been tons of great stuff coming out these past year. If I just listed out everything I’d recommend from the past few years I’d be here all day typing, but if there’s a genre that you’re looking for (that isn’t cyberpunk unfortunately) there’s probably been good anime made for it recently.

Is there a good story that ends with the couple breaking up, and left it at that? That would certainly be daring, and different.

I read one recently, but everyone involved is kinda crazy (including the protagonist) so it made sense when they called it off.

It was a strange episode, but I’d rather rewatch Toys in the Attic than the movie.

If I’m being honest I thought this movie was the weakest part of Cowboy Bebop. I don’t think the fight choreography or the writing held up to the standard set by the TV show.

Oh no, I get all that. But I’m not usually seeing one chapter adapted into one episode. Usually it’s more like a third of a volume.

This is actually waaaaaay less of a problem than it used to be. It’s a bummer that we usually get shorter seasons now, but the tradeoff is that it’s far less common for filler to be injected into the story to drag things out than it used to be.