Comment on There is no fix for Intel’s crashing 13th and 14th Gen CPUs — any damage is permanent
BeatTakeshi@lemmy.world 3 months ago
What did they mess from 12th?
13th and 14th gen are literally the exact same hardware as 12th gen, but with boosted clock speeds and power requirements.
But they made the rookie mistake of not adequately dealing with heat dissipation (which is easy to make when overclocking,) and chips are burning out.
I don’t think that the voltage issue is simply heat, not unless it is some kind of extremely-localized or extremely-short-in-time issue internal to the chip. I hit the problem with a very hefty water cooler that didn’t let the attached processor ever get very warm, at least as the processor reported temperatures.
Wendell, at Level1Techs, who did an earlier video with Steve Burke talking about this, looked over a dataset of hundreds of machines. They were running with conservative speed settings, in a datacenter where all temperatures were being logged, and he said that the hottest he ever saw on any hotspot on any processor in his dataset was, IIRC, 85 degrees, and normally they were well below that. He saw about a 50% failure rate.
If we hit the problem on our well-cooled CPUs, if the CPU simply getting hot were a problem, I’d have expected people running them in hotter environments to have slammed into the thing immediately. Ditto for Intel – I’d guess (I’d hope) that part of their QA cycle involves running the processors in an industrial oven, as a way to simulate more-serious conditions.
It’s not about the CPU package getting too hot, it’s about a specific set of transistors getting too hot. I think I read they’re between the processing units and the cache. The size of these transistors combined is probably around a couple mm square. Unless you etch the package back you can’t measure them precisely. And if you etch that you can’t dissipate their temperature so you can rub CPU at maximum load.
Cort@lemmy.world 3 months ago
13th & 14th Gen were just higher voltage and clock speed and boost time limit versions of 12th Gen. It seems like they just over did it
CatZoomies@lemmy.world 3 months ago
Holy crap I barely escaped. I needed an upgrade years ago and settled on the i7-12700k. After I ride this chip out I’m switching to AMD.
I really hope customers get justice in this debacle. We need a lawsuit now.
BobGnarley@lemm.ee 3 months ago
Money grab because they didn’t have anything new to actually bring to the table this time.