For anyone else that didn’t read the article (or can’t hear words in parentheses because they are too quiet):
According to a report from 404 Media, some of those players have been adding fake beaches to OpenStreetMap so they could have easier access to the beach biome in Pokémon Go (though the game Go initially used Google Maps data, it apparently switched to OpenStreetMap at some point in 2017).
empireOfLove2@lemmy.dbzer0.com 6 months ago
If they used Google maps, Niantic would have to pay Google. That’s no Bueno. Why pay for content critical to your apps success when you could just freeload on volunteers work instead?
n2burns@lemmy.ca 6 months ago
I know this seems like Niantic is free-loading, but this is intentionally-allowed by the ODbL license and honestly, might be a good business decision even without considering the licensing fees. OSM is almost 20 years old and as a community led project, is probably more predictable and stable than a Google license which could change drastically from one contract to the next.
As a OSM contributor, I’m more than happy to see my work used this way, and as @QuadratureSurfer@lemmy.world pointed out, OSM has seen a lot of benefit too.
kamenlady@lemmy.world 6 months ago
Don’t get any changes reviewed before , you know, really replacing map data ? I’m just curious. There are a lot of players worldwide, I can imagine the game going strong for another few years and OSM ending up choke full of areas that were pokemon’d and made unusable.
joostjakob@lemmy.world 6 months ago
“Made unusable”: that’s not how it works. Even with occasional vandalism, there’s so much more people positively contributing, that overall the map just keeps on getting better and better.
n2burns@lemmy.ca 6 months ago
I’m a pretty junior contributor (I spent a couple years completing quests on StreetComplete and only have been adding new buildings, etc for a few weeks). I don’t know a ton about how the organization is run, so I can only talk from my experiences. I’ve been able to upload changes which will be live before they will be reviewed. I know there are reviewers who go through areas regularly, but they definitely don’t cover everywhere. I’m not sure if OSM has the ability to lockdown areas with frequent vandalism.
Fisch@discuss.tchncs.de 6 months ago
From what I can tell, changes are just uploaded immediately. I think If someone adds wrong data, another contributor can revert it.
Almrond@lemmy.world 6 months ago
Yeah, and the consequence of them using the dataset is massive amounts of people contribute useful data to the project. It is a fair exchange in my opinion. There are lots of reasons to hate Pokemon Go, but this isn’t one of them. You can use the maps too, and they are far better as a result of PGO using them.
tal@lemmy.today 6 months ago
Part of – if not the primary point – of OSM is that people can use its database in their projects. That’s a feature, not a bug. They could have very readily restricted commercial use of the database and chose not to do so.
otp@sh.itjust.works 6 months ago
Pokemon Go brought more users to OpenMaps, so there was definitely some mutual benefit going on.
Vandals, yes, but plenty of legit contributers, too.
catloaf@lemm.ee 6 months ago
Niantic is a Google spinoff, and the data they generated for Ingress was used for Google Maps. I’m surprised they don’t have a special deal with Google.
abhibeckert@lemmy.world 6 months ago
Google doesn’t own most of their map data - they license it off other companies that have spent decades and billions of dollars collecting map data from all around the world.
So even if Google gives a project a “special deal” it’s still not going to be free. Open Street Map, on the other hand, is totally free. And in some ways it’s better than Google Maps — because it has millions of people contributing to the map. No commercial mapping company can come close to that.
lowleveldata@programming.dev 6 months ago
Also that you don’t want to be depending on Google’s products if you don’t want to revamp every 2~3 years
kamenlady@lemmy.world 6 months ago
Google Maps Api has been reliable for a very long time.
Google ain’t stupid, they know which products they can google around and which not. Google Ads, Analytics and Maps customers are too valuable for them.