If this is a loss, a loss compared to what? Centralised servers? If Lemmy was a centralised server, this would’ve taken the while site down. As another commenter mentioned, if the US government decides take Reddit down, the whole service would be lost. But in the Fediverse no single government can stop it.
Chozo@kbin.social 1 year ago
@renwillis I'm not so sure this is a "win", since the Fediverse wasn't specifically targeted by any entity involved to begin with. If anything, it's just a straight-up loss to the communities that have to reassemble themselves under a new domain again, many of whom were probably mostly new users to the Fediverse to begin with, and are likely to be turned off by this experience. If anything, this just exposes that the Fediverse is significantly sustained by flimsy, free/cheap platforms that are vulnerable to disappearing without any notice. That doesn't exactly instill faith.
It's a really bad look, to be perfectly honest.
puppy@lemmy.world 1 year ago
Meowoem@sh.itjust.works 1 year ago
I do kinda agree, this isn’t great for general adoption but it’s a vital learning curve and hopefully smart people in the community will help develop ways to avoid it going forward and tools to fix it when it does happen
ebits21@lemmy.ca 1 year ago
We NEED better abilities to migrate accounts to other instances like with Mastodon!
renwillis@mstdn.social 1 year ago
@Chozo @fediverse disagree. It's another argument for decentralization that 1 entity taking down another entity doesn't take down the whole system.
If the US seized Reddit.com today, the whole site would just be gone. Poof!
The US could seize 1000 servers today and yet the Fediverse would continue on.
zoats@lemmy.dbzer0.com 1 year ago
i don’t think you understand how domains work.
p03locke@lemmy.dbzer0.com 1 year ago
If lemmy.world went down, so would most of Lemmy, so this is already a huge problem.
Chozo@kbin.social 1 year ago
@renwillis The Fediverse is more than just the collective network. It's also the individual communities, some of which no longer exist right now. Those communities are now scrambling to figure out what to do.
Yes, the whole of the Fediverse is just fine. But the overall health of the Fediverse relies heavily on the health of individual communities.
EatMyDick@lemmy.world 1 year ago
I could also get hot by lightning there times a day but I don’t optimize for it. This is a lol and definitely points back to how shitty personal servers may be. I for one hope a .org starts a monitizartion scheme, deals with the privacy issues this community blatantly ignores, and hires some professionals who actually know what they are doing.