Comment

Comment on Announcing Winners of the 2025 Fediverse Anime Awards

Meta Comment:

Thanks again, everybody that voted! If you want to check out the anonymized ballot information and inspect the code I used to process the votes, you can find a repository I made here.

Total turnout this year (~25 votes) was down quite a bit compared to last year (~90 votes). I think there were a couple contributing factors to this:

The private-message voting system was new, and I don’t think it seems like it was popular. Last year I had run a survey site that lets people fill out a web form for their vote. However, the software was really flaky on the backend side of things and I didn’t want to run it again. Also, there was not really any way to prevent somebody from voting multiple times because I couldn’t tie a vote to a user account.
Last year’s voting period happened over the holidays, and I suspect that boosted turnout.
I think total overall activity is down compared to a year ago, especially so since we are in the middle of a season. The active user count always tends to tick up when a new season kicks off, but then falls back down a bit to coast until the next season sees another bit of a spike. So, doing these awards in the middle of a season probably didn’t help turnout.

Please feel free to let me know if you have any ideas for improvement in the future. Whether that is about the voting process, nomination process, timing, whatever…

As for the award winners, there were a couple titles that really soaked up lots of votes in any category they were nominated for. Specifically, CITY, Apocalypse Hotel, and Chainsaw Man - Reze Arc got a huge portion of the voteshare whenever they were nominated. So, if there is any takeaway from these awards for me, it’s that those are this community’s standout favorites from last year.

Other interesting things I noticed:

I was glad to see Ninkoro doing so well in the Best Comedy category. I loved the dark humor in that series so much, and the anime really elevated the source material in lots of ways. Glad to see others agreed!
I was also happy to see Rock is a Lady’s Modesty do well in the OST category. It’s always nice when an anime about music actually has good music in it.
I found it interesting that Maomao absolutely ran away with the voting for best Voice Acting, but she didn’t even make the nomination list for best character. In fact, Shisui received more nominations than Maomao for best character.

source

Sort:hotnew top

braindamagebuddy@lemmy.world ⁨3⁩ ⁨days⁩ ago
Yeah not going to lie the private message thing was pretty brutal. Filling out the template on mobile takes a good amount of effort. I also think ranked choice may discourage some from voting since people may not know each of the choices very well.

Thanks for hosting again this year and trying things out though.

source
- wjs018@ani.social ⁨3⁩ ⁨days⁩ ago
  Yeah…it won’t be private messages next year for sure. Lesson learned!
  
  source
- ReluctantlyZen@ani.social ⁨2⁩ ⁨days⁩ ago
  
  I also think ranked choice may discourage some from voting since people may not know each of the choices very well.
  
  Yeah I wondered about that too. I left out the ones I didn’t watch from my voting list, but that feels a little unfair
  
  source
Crank@ani.social ⁨2⁩ ⁨days⁩ ago
First of all, big thanks for making this happen.

As for the factors contributing to lower turnout, I think the following might have affected it:

RCV voting system - it’s harder to understand than your typical voting system where you only cast one vote for your favorite show. It might be more fair overall, but people might have questions like:

does specifying the second, the third choice, and so on, affect the chances of my first choice winning?

if I didn’t watch all the nominated shows, should I include them in my ballot at all?
I think instead of thinking this through, people might just decide that I don’t understand this system, I don’t want to think about it, so I will not vote at all

in the nominations phase: not having a list to choose from, and having to come up with the nominees on your own. I think such list should include not just the titles but also posters to make the search easier (also needs to be mobile friendly)

having to edit a markdown file by hand. It might be discouraging on a desktop computer but it’s straight up annoying on mobile devices, and I imagine that more than a half of the userbase uses their mobile phones to browse social media.

as others already mentioned, the user interface of Lemmy doesn’t make it obvious where do you send a private message. Perhaps there’s some way to create a direct link, like ani.social/create_private_message/5000605 ? But that only works if someone is registered on ani.social. Anyway, if you plan to use private messages in some way again next year, I think it would be a good idea to explain how to send one (which would be challenging anyway, because each mobile client does it in its own way)

Sorry if it came out as overly critical. It wasn’t my intention. I know it’s hard to come up with a good solution that satisfies everyone and I’m grateful for all the work you’ve done.
source
Endmaker@ani.social ⁨3⁩ ⁨days⁩ ago
May I trouble you to update this post to show the top 3 nominees for each category, along with their final vote count?

source
- wjs018@ani.social ⁨3⁩ ⁨days⁩ ago
  Ranked choice voting doesn’t allow a simple top X candidates due to the way votes can transfer between rounds. If you want to see how each category’s voting rounds went, you can see them all here.
  
  In the list below, I have listed the second-highest receiver(s) of votes in the final voting round:
  
  2025 Anime Series of the Year - CITY the Animation
  
  2025 Anime Film of the Year - 100 Meters
  
  2025 Anime Character of the Year - Izumi Wako (CITY the Animation)
  
  Best Comedy - Ninkoro and 100 Girlfriends (tie)
  
  Best Drama - Summer Hikaru Died
  
  Best Fantasy/Adventure - Secrets of the Silent Witch
  
  Best Romance - Fragrant Flower
  
  Best Slice of Life - Apocalypse Hotel
  
  Best Action - Dan Da Dan Season 2
  
  Best Animation - Chainsaw Man Reze Arc
  
  Best Soundtrack - Rock is a Lady’s Modesty and Umamusume Cinderella Gray (tie)
  
  Best Voice Acting - Mikako Komatsu (Nagumo from CITY the Animation)
  
  Best Musical Sequence - Kaseijin by Yorushika - Shoushimin Season 2 OP
  
  source
ReluctantlyZen@ani.social ⁨2⁩ ⁨days⁩ ago

Total turnout this year (~25 votes) was down quite a bit compared to last year (~90 votes).

Damn, that’s very low. I figured it’d be higher, given the amount of upvotes.

The private-message voting system was new, and I don’t think it seems like it was popular.

Yeah, it wasn’t great tbh. The whole markdown list was a bit tedious. Can’t do it on a phone well either. But also, I find private messaging very unintuitive on Lemmy. I opened my laptop to fill it out, but it took a while before I found the chat thing (in the notifications area apparently).

I found it interesting that Maomao absolutely ran away with the voting for best Voice Acting, but she didn’t even make the nomination list for best character. In fact, Shisui received more nominations than Maomao for best character.

I think Maomao is great, but I think Shisui meant more for this season than Maomao did.

source
OmegaSunkey@ani.social ⁨2⁩ ⁨days⁩ ago
i personally didnt vote this year because i didnt see any of the animes listed

source