Comment on [Episode] Gnosia - Episode 14 discussion

Endmaker@ani.social ⁨18⁩ ⁨hours⁩ ago

I tried playing through the game:

game break-down

### Day 1 The game started with 15 players There were 3 Gnosia onboard, along with 1 each of Engineer, Doctor, Guardian Angel and AC Follower - An assumption is that an AC Follower cannot hold any other credentials - Another assumption is that Yuri is a reliable narrator - One more assumption is that there is indeed an AC Follower onboard - One last assumption is that everyone brought their A-game to the table - even Comet! - Yuri was confirmed to be the Engineer - Yuriko and Otome were confirmed to ordinary humans (on guard duty) Sha Ming wanted to nap, but otherwise stayed in the meeting room with the rest of them - Sha Ming tends to sacrifice himself / throw the game when he was Gnosia in past loops - Since he was playing the game normally, he is more likely to not be Gnosia Racqio wanted someone with credentials to step forward and make their identities known Jonas wanted someone with credentials to step forward and make their identities known Shigemichi claimed to be human Yuriko was put into cold sleep Comet tried convincing Yuri that Shigemichi is Gnosia - Comet was shown to be good at detecting lies in past loops Jina found Yuri suspicious when they shared a meal together Otome was eliminated by Gnosia during the warp — ### Day 2 Stella wanted someone with credentials to step forward and make their identities known Yuri revealed that he is the Engineer Jonas counter-claimed the Engineer role - Current possibility for Jonas: either a Gnosia or AC Follower Yuri confirmed that Kukrushka is human Jonas claimed that Setsu is human - if Jonas is Gnosia, Setsu is almost certainly a human - if Jonas is AC Follower, Setsu may be human or Gnosia Racqio wanted to hear the Engineers’ reasoning behind their claims Chipie pointed out that Comet tried convincing him that Shigemichi is Gnosia - Comet tried persuading everyone else that Shigemichi is Gnosia - Chipie seemed to support Comet Shigemichi was put into cold sleep - 8 votes for Shigemichi - 5 votes for Comet Kukrushka claimed to be the Guardian Angel while alone with Yuri - Kukrushka believed Yuri’s claim of being the Engineer when he identified her as a human - Kukrushka claimed that she would protect Yuri Jina was eliminated by Gnosia during the warp — ### Day 3 Sha Ming suggested putting everyone into cold sleep Chipie wanted the Doctor to step forward and make their identity known Remnan claimed to be the Doctor - Current possibility for Remnan: could be Doctor, Gnosia or AC Follower Racqio claimed to be the Doctor - Current possibility for Racqio: could be Doctor, Gnosia or AC Follower Remnan claimed that Shigemichi was human Racqio claimed that Shigemichi was human If one of Remnan / Racqio is Doctor and the other is Gnosia: - the Doctor confirmed that Shigemichi is indeed human - which means that Comet is looking suspicious - Comet is likely to be AC Follower as Gnosia should not betray each other If one of Remnan / Racqio is Doctor and the other is AC Follower: - the Doctor confirmed that Shigemichi is indeed human - which means that Comet is looking suspicious - Comet is likely to be Gnosia as there should only be 1 AC Follower If one of Remnan / Racqio is Gnosia and the other is AC Follower: - they may both be lying so Shigemichi may be human or Gnosia - if Shigemichi is human, then the Remnan / Racqio saying so would place suspicion on Comet, essentially betraying their teammate (which should not happen) - if Shigemichi is Gnosia, then the Remnan / Racqio just wanted to use the chance to put a human - Comet - into cold sleep Jonas claimed that Comet is Gnosia Yuri confirmed that Comet is Gnosia - Gnosia should not betray each other, so Remnan / Racqio ought to be Doctor and AC Follower - otherwise, if they were Gnosia, their previous claims of Shigemichi being human seriously sabotaged their teammate / Comet - unless it is a big-brain play, where the Gnosia team coordinated this and planned to sacrifice Comet? Comet was put into cold sleep - regardless of whether Shigemichi or Comet was Gnosia, it seemed that at least one of the 3 Gnosia had been put into cold sleep Nobody was eliminated during the warp - presumably, Kukrushka successfully protected Yuri from a Gnosia attack — ### Day 4 Remnan claimed that Comet is Gnosia Racqio claimed that Comet is Gnosia Yuri confirmed(?) that Racqio is Gnosia Maybe Yuri suspected that Racqio is the AC Follower and wanted him in cold sleep - however, the real Doctor, Remnan, would see that Racqio is human and sensed that something is amiss - this like may backfire on Yuri The other possibility is that Racqio is indeed Gnosia - then there was indeed a sacrificial play involving Comet


Final standings / predictions:

Dead

  1. Yuriko - human (cold sleep)
  2. Otome - human (eliminated by Gnosia)
  3. Jina - human (eliminated by Gnosia)
  4. Shigemichi - human (cold sleep)
  5. Comet - Gnosia (cold sleep)

Alive

  1. Yuri - Engineer
  2. Kukrushka - Guardian Angel
  3. Jonas - AC Follower
  4. Remnan - Doctor
  5. Racqio - Gnosia
  6. Chipie - human?
  7. Sha Ming - human?
  8. Setsu - human?
  9. Stella - human?
  10. SQ - human?

The number of roles are not adding up. One of Chipie, Sha Ming, Setsu, Stella or SQ has to be Gnosia or AC Follower (or an incompetent doctor, but let’s rule this out).

I am guessing it’s either Setsu or Stella who is the last Gnosia.

source
Sort:hotnewtop