This is everywhere on the internet. I think it’s people looking for an easy way out in arguing. Purposely include a few logic fallacies and watch as the vast majority of people latch onto them. Ignoring any previous points they were trying to make. I like ad hominem.
Ceedoestrees@lemmy.world 2 days ago
Appeal to Fallacy. It might not be a fallacy. A fallacy doesn’t make an argument wrong. There are degrees of fallacies. Claiming a statement is wrong because there might be a fallacy is a thought-ending argument. There’s more nuance and relatability in rhetoric. Refusing to engage because someone’s using a fallacy is reasonable, but calling it by name isn’t a magic spell that forces someone to throw in the towel.
pahlimur@lemmy.world 2 days ago
0ops@lemm.ee 2 days ago
This is a good one. The use of fallacies doesn’t necessarily void an argument, it just fails to support it logically.
For example, I could craft a perfect, clean, cold-cut argument so water-tight and beautiful that even ben-fucking-shapiro would have a come-to-jesus. Calling my opponent a “dickhead” at the end (ad hominem) doesn’t prove anything, but it doesn’t nullify the entire rest of the argument either. Plus it’s fun.
Ceedoestrees@lemmy.world 2 days ago
I agree, an argument can be a narrative, too. One where the dickhead is the second person.