I was one of the downvotes. Clusivity, as described in your article does not apply to y’all. It’s You All…it will never include the speaker.
It’d have to be something like w’all to apply.
Comment on The mist Texan of all expressions - Y'All - is ungendered and therefore woke
pythonoob@programming.dev 10 months agoY’all is exclusive. All y’all is inclusive.
If I walk into a party in a house and a group of my friends are there and I say ‘what are y’all doing here?’, I’m only talking to my friends.
If I walk into my own house and there’s a party there and I say ‘what are all y’all doing here?’ I’m addressing everyone of the hoodlums in my house.
chakan2@lemmy.world 10 months ago
Hadriscus@lemm.ee 10 months ago
“Anyway, here’s wonderw’all”
Art3sian@lemmy.world 10 months ago
We’re very inclusive and in Australia also.
‘G’day you bunch of cunts’ means hello to everyone male, female, known and unknown.
We’re very polite over here.
pythonoob@programming.dev 10 months ago
How very nice of all you cunts over there
nednobbins@lemm.ee 10 months ago
Yeah. We mostly think of grammatical number as a simple choice of singular vs plural but that’s not what we do in real life.
We generally have multiple labels that describe the concept of progressively expanding circles of what’s included when we think of ourselves.
There’s the very narrow sense of I/me/myself. We have various expansions around us/all’y’all. Jamaicans have the phrase “I and I” which focuses on the individual but explicitly calls out the connection with others.
gmtom@lemmy.world 10 months ago
Getting pressed enough about a single downvote to make an edit is cringe.