iglou
@iglou@programming.dev
- Comment on AI-generated code contains more bugs and errors than human output 1 day ago:
And now instead of understanding the functions, parameters, syntax and quirks yourself, to be able to produce quality code, which is the job of a software engineer, you ask an LLM to spit out code that seem to be working, do that again, and again, and again, and call it a day.
And then I’ll be hired to fix it.
- Comment on AI-generated code contains more bugs and errors than human output 2 days ago:
The things I have seen from devs who thought they could lie and pretend they didn’t use AI…
- Comment on AI-generated code contains more bugs and errors than human output 2 days ago:
The Turing test becomes absolutely useless when the product is developed with the goal of beating the Turing test.
- Comment on AI-generated code contains more bugs and errors than human output 2 days ago:
I am a professional software engineer, and my experience is the complete opposite. It does it faster and cheaper, yes, but also noticeably worse, and having to proofread the output, fix and refactor ends up taking more time than I would have taken writing it myself.
- Comment on Mozilla’s new CEO is doubling down on an AI future for Firefox 1 week ago:
I’m not having, as I said before, any issues with Gecko
Good for you!
- Comment on Mozilla’s new CEO is doubling down on an AI future for Firefox 1 week ago:
I say that as a web developer myself. Gecko has become problematic to work with. It’s not the web devs fault that Gecko is now full of odd quirks.
- Comment on Mozilla’s new CEO is doubling down on an AI future for Firefox 1 week ago:
If your only criterium is the presence of AI, then of course it doesn’t matter.
But Firefox has been degrading far before AI was even hyped. Mozilla basically gave up on its development as they lost their market share. Full of bugs, poor implementation of new standards, terrible optimization… That’s why I switched to a Chromium based browser. Not because of AI.
- Comment on Mozilla’s new CEO is doubling down on an AI future for Firefox 1 week ago:
Unforunately, there is no solid alternative at the moment. Firefox used to be great, but the quality of the browser has been consistently declining for years now. In terms of features, stability, and accuracy. The various forks I tested back when I couldn’t deal with Firefox’s issues had the exact same issues.
At least Vivaldi is european.
- Comment on Mozilla’s new CEO is doubling down on an AI future for Firefox 1 week ago:
Vivaldi is Chromium based
Yes. And? It is open source, and Vivaldi modifies it heavily.
You’re criticizing browsers based on “Shitty Browser A” while promoting browsers based on “Shitty Browser B”. Both categories are heavily modified and just as viable.
People need to stop being scared of Chromium-based browsers.
- Comment on Samsung to halt SATA SSD production, leaker warns of up to 18 months of SSD price pressure, worse than Micron ending consumer RAM 1 week ago:
Exactly this. Micron ended their consumer RAM. Sansung here is just stopping producing something that is arguably outdated, and has a perfectly fine, already more available, most often cheaper or equivalent modern replacement.
- Comment on Introducing Proton Sheets 2 weeks ago:
Problem is the e2e encryption. The bridge basically decrypts your emails and makes them locally accessible.
- Comment on Introducing Proton Sheets 2 weeks ago:
It is technically impossible at the moment to keep your emails end-to-end encrypted and not have to use a bridge for your client of choice. It will only be possible if your client of choice partners with Proton to integrate them, or if a standard for e2e encrypted emails pops up and both Proton and your client adopt it.
- Comment on Introducing Proton Sheets 2 weeks ago:
Because forking a buggy suite isn’t always the best choice? If they have the ressources, and they do, making their own is best for everyone. More choices.
- Comment on YSK: The Invention Secrecy Act is a US federal law authorizing the government to suppress disclosure of certain inventions for reasons of national security. 6,543 inventions are currently suppressed. 5 weeks ago:
That is not how the internet works
- Comment on Cloudflare blames massive internet outage on 'latent bug' 5 weeks ago:
Obviousness? If you mass layoff your tech staff, you take the risk of more technical failures.
A smaller staff cannot do the same work as a larger one, and I guarantee you they’re being asked to progress at the same speed. So, the tradeoff is on the quality of the product and the testing, not on the speed of development.
- Comment on Mastodon says it doesn't 'have the means' to comply with age verification laws 3 months ago:
Yeah, considering it is not impossible to geoblock per instance, they could.
- Comment on OpenAI Says It's Scanning Users' ChatGPT Conversations and Reporting Content to the Police 3 months ago:
Not a single part of your answer is about how the brain works.
Concepts are not things in your brain.
Consciousness is a concept. It doesn’t exist in your brain.
Thinking is how a human uses their brain.
I’m asking about how the brain itself functions to intepret natural language.
- Comment on OpenAI Says It's Scanning Users' ChatGPT Conversations and Reporting Content to the Police 3 months ago:
That doesn’t answer the question you quoted.
- Comment on OpenAI Says It's Scanning Users' ChatGPT Conversations and Reporting Content to the Police 3 months ago:
Of course the “understanding” of an LLM is limited. Because the entire technology is new, and it’s far from being anywhere close to being able to understand to the level of a human.
But I disagree with your understanding of how an LLM works. At its lower level, it’s a bunch on connected artifical neurons, not that different from a human brain. Now please don’t read this as me saying it’s as good as a human brain. It’s definitely not, but its inner workings are not so far. As a matter of fact, there is active effort to make artificial neurons behave as close as possible to a human neuron.
If it was just statistics, it wouldn’t be so difficult to look at the trained model and identify what does what. But just like the human brain, it is incredidbly difficult to understand that. We just have a general idea.
So it does understand, to a limited extent. Just like a human, it won’t understand what it hasn’t been exposed to. And unlike a human, it is exposed to a very limited set of data.
You’re putting the difference between a human’s “understanding” and an LLM’s “understanding” in the meaning of the word “understanding”, which is just a shortcut to say that they can’t be compared. The actual difference is in the scope of understanding.
A lot of the efforts in the AI fields gravitate around imitating a human brain. Which makes sense, as it is the only thing we know that is capable of doing what we want an AI to do. LLMs are no different, but their scope is limited.
- Comment on OpenAI Says It's Scanning Users' ChatGPT Conversations and Reporting Content to the Police 3 months ago:
They are talking at a technical level only on one side of the comparison. It makes the entire discussion pointless. If you’re going to compare the understanding of a neural network and the understanding of a human brain, you have to go into depth on both sides.
Mysticism? Lmao. Where? Do you know what the word means?
- Comment on OpenAI Says It's Scanning Users' ChatGPT Conversations and Reporting Content to the Police 3 months ago:
You’re entering a more philosophical debate than a technical one, because for this point to make any sense, you’d have to define what “understanding” language means for a human in a level as low as what you’re describing for an LLM.
Can you affirm that what a human brain does to understand language is so different to what an LLM does?
I’m not saying an LLM is smart, but saying that it doesn’t understand, when having computers “understand” natural language is the core of NLP, is meh.
- Comment on OpenAI Says It's Scanning Users' ChatGPT Conversations and Reporting Content to the Police 3 months ago:
That is actually incorrect. It is also a language understanding tool. You don’t have an LLM without NLP. NLP includes processing and understanding natural language.
- Comment on Google will require developer verification for Android apps outside the Play Store 3 months ago:
Haha. Ha.
- Comment on I'm glad I got a glass dinner table: otherwise I'd never know how much gunk my young child smears in the underside of the table 4 months ago:
It can definitely break when mishandled. With kids you probably don’t want glass furniture.
- Comment on Starlink tries to block Virginia’s plan to bring fiber Internet to residents 4 months ago:
Good luck having that shitty tech win over Europe, where fiber is proliferating particularly quickly. We all know sattelite internet cannot come close to the speed and reliability of fiber.
Plus we hate Musk.
It’s good for remote areas and at sea, it’s shit everywhere else
- Comment on YSK that despite being outside of US jurisdiction, Lego has dropped diversity and inclusion terminology from its annual report 4 months ago:
Exactly. All that the stats do in this case is show what everyone knows: There is a racism problem in hiring.
It doesn’t help prove anything in a court of law, and the multitude of excuses to hide racism make it almost impossible to prove that the true reason is racism.
- Comment on YSK that despite being outside of US jurisdiction, Lego has dropped diversity and inclusion terminology from its annual report 4 months ago:
I’m not certain having data on people’s ethnicity is helping at all with discrimination on hiring.
There is laws in France against discrimination as well. The problem isn’t that there isn’t ethnic data, the problem is that it’s really hard to prove that a candidate was rejected because of their ethnicity.
I’d be happy to be proven wrong though.
- Comment on GitHub is no longer independent at Microsoft after CEO resignation 4 months ago:
For a small to medium company it’s not necessarily worth it.
- Comment on GitHub is no longer independent at Microsoft after CEO resignation 4 months ago:
I use my own gitea server
- Comment on How do I stop Docker trying to pull from IPv6? 4 months ago:
At this point I am assuming that it is actually a docker issue.
Can you show your docker daemon configuration?
Hard to tell where it is on your machine. Try ~/.docker/daemon.json, or maybe /etc/docker/daemon.json… Else look for it haha