Anna’s Archive’s idealism doesn’t quite survive its own blog post
186 million. Not 86 million. There’s 100 million difference there.
Submitted 1 day ago by BrikoX@lemmy.zip to technology@lemmy.zip
https://www.theregister.com/2025/12/22/hacktivists_scrape_songs_spotify/
Anna’s Archive’s idealism doesn’t quite survive its own blog post
186 million. Not 86 million. There’s 100 million difference there.
did not bother reading the source blog
That’s rich given the source blog says “86 million music files” the paragraph after saying 186 million ISRCs. You apparently read less of it than The Register’s writer did.
You are confusing “186 million unique ISRCs” with “86 million music files”.
By not bothering with all the musical chaff in Spotify’s catalog, the Anna’s Archive team is apparently content to let those less popular songs languish despite their claim to want to avoid focusing on just the most popular artists.
Okay Mr Register writer, tell me how you would handle creating and wrangling a petabyte+ torrent.
I don’t think there’s any reason to trust Spotify saying they’ve figured out how ppl were scraping. As far as I’m aware I don’t think AA mentioned how they were scraping
I’d love to make a similar thing with google maps and store their high resolution remote sensing images in a georeferenced format, but I don’t have enough storage for even 1% of that.
I think Anna’s archive actually has a bounty on that or at least a very related task.
So if you’ve found a way to economically scrape the street view 360° pictures definitely let them know. As far as I understand if you can prove you have a working method for scraping they will do what they can in terms of infrastructure and such to get it done.
The gitlab on which this is explained is down for me atm.
Thanks for letting me know. I will definitely check it out in my free time after the holidays!
Yes, “preserve culture” 😉
So, they are complaining about how Spotify is under paying and robbing the artist, and they thought well, the solution would be to dumb all their music online for free?
Pirating music is genuinely just not worth the effort so I honestly belive them. Probably didn’t scrape all of them simply because that’s a petabyte of storage or more.
with 86 million music files, representing around 99.6% of listens.
I’m not sure exactly how “listens” maps on to total songs, but it sounds like they got almost all of them
Over 250 million total so about 1/3.
6nk06@sh.itjust.works 1 day ago
I love how titles change. Compare it with “Hacktivist named Zuck scrapes Anna’s archive to steal more billions.”
purplemonkeymad@programming.dev 1 day ago
I know for sure all the ai companies are on that torrent. Expect new music models.