Comment on Baidu: Driverless Car Hits Jaywalker in China
MajinBlayze@lemmy.world 4 months agoIs every scenario on that site a case of break failure? As a presumably electric vehicle it should be able to use regenerative breaking to stop or slow, or even rub against the guardrails in the side in each instance I saw
There’s also no accounting for probabilities, or the plethora of bad decisions required to put the car going what must be highway speeds down a city stroad with a sudden, undetectable complete break system failure.
This “test” is pure, unadulterated propaganda.
“here, take these extremely specific made up scenarios that PROVE I AM RIGHT UNEQUIVOCALLY except for the fact that all of them are edge cases, do not represent any of the actual fatalities we have seen and in no way are any of them representative of the case that sparked the whole discussion”
I think I’ll skip the “Ai is always good and you’re just too stupid to get why it should be allowed to kill people” website.
14th_cylon@lemm.ee 4 months ago
yeah, you didn’t get it at all…
oh hey, you are starting to get it 😂
maybe, when you finally understand what someone is trying to tell you, act less smug, don’t try to pretend you just got them, and you will look less like a clown.
the experiment is not about technical details, it is trying to convey the message that “what is the right thing to do” is not as easy to establish as you might think.
because yes, most people will tell you to protect more people at the expense of less, but that usually lasts only until the moment when they are part of the smaller group.
Balex@lemmy.world 4 months ago
While I do agree that there are scenarios that are very complicated, I feel like this website does a very poor job at showing those. Almost every single scenario they show doesn’t make sense at all. Why are there barriers on one side of the road, why does half the crosswalk have a red light while the other half has a green light?
14th_cylon@lemm.ee 4 months ago
what, have you never seen a construction on the road? have you never seen a traffic light, that is manually activated?
both of these scenarios are happening on a daily basis in real life.
and they are here so you can think about the decision. is the car occupant’s life more valuable than the life of innocent bystander (eh, is bywalker a word)? does that change when one group is bigger in numbers? does it change when one group is obeying law and the other one not?
i have answered basically same question here: lemm.ee/post/36643403/13142015