There is some truth to what you say but the game is more than a sum of its parts. Even though individual strokes of game dev brush may be not perfect the whole package as of today creates memorable and unforgettable experience.

However the big flaw that bothers me is how shallowly cyberpunk genre was treated. It was disfigured to capitalism bad m’kay and neon vistas. Johnny was a bloody idiot because of the shortcomings of writing. Yet some individual characters and stories are written masterfully even if the world barely holds together. Which creates sort of uncanny effect because the writing of some characters is so good that I feel like they live in this not belivable world. When I finished some side story I felt finished with the game.