Comment on Reddit: Return Of The Junk Stock IPO
lvxferre@mander.xyz 8 months ago
This is one of those rare cases where what is being said is less interesting than who says it.
What: Reddit stock is junk, the IPO will fail hard, and anyone investing on it is begging to lose money. I believe that most people discussing this in Lemmy already know that, so the info isn’t new here.
Who: Forbes. Forbes’ target audience is investors; greedy vulture capitalists love it. So if Forbes says “it’ll sink!”, investors are less eager to buy stock, and that sinks the stonks even further. So what Forbes says is often a self-fulfilling prophecy.
I’m glad that Forbes is doing it. I want to see Reddit die.
“Forbes” is not the Forbes you are referring to. It’s a blogging platform that shows the forbes name and claims they’re “Contributors” but isn’t actually “Forbes Magazine” which is what investors actually trust.
Basically this is just some shitbag pretending to be classy by hiding behind someone who sold him that space. There’s a ton of shit Video Game “Articles” on the site too, same story(masquerade), same value (low) , same respectability (none)
Don’t talk shit about Paul Tassi, he’s the best thing they have going on that part of the site (when he’s not going off about Dedstiny 2)
One of the most convincing points is …
competition has had many years to acquire Reddit prior to this IPO and have chosen not too. Acquiring Reddit now wouldn’t create all that much value for a competing social platform.
I sure as hell wouldn’t acquire a company for a product that has a near identical, free, open-source alternative that’s in active use.
Well, at least one person thought it was a good idea to acquire a Mastodon competitor, and they paid a pretty penny for it
Compare to Lemmy’s userbase, which is anti-capitalist and clearly has a bone to pick with reddit. If I had to value Lemmy it would be for the cost of hardware and operations alone.
Which is kinda what Reddit should be valued at, because its a community oriented site, the value is never in the contributions. They can always pack up and leave. Anyone thinking there’s a value in community oriented sites is being fooled.
0.1% of users isn’t exactly a threat to their model.
Just like Reddit wasn’t a threat to Digg.
I absolutely would, for the users. But only if the userbase wasn’t full of Nazis and pedophiles, so reddit is still a no for me.
Yes it’s a bit confusing with that “Forbes” name?
But the article is good IMO, and has many 100% valid points.
stealth_cookies@lemmy.ca 8 months ago
Note that this is a “contributor” post, which is essentially their sneaky working for editorial. It isn’t a real Forbes article and anyone that knows the Forbes website won’t pay any attention to the article.
taiyang@lemmy.world 8 months ago
Very important distinction! Even I’ve written “contributor” posts on behalf is a company when I was moon lighting for a block chain startup. They’re not quite ads, but you very much can buy your way into that.
erlend_sh@lemmy.world 8 months ago
It will still have made the rounds, since it trended on HN: news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39667026
rimu@piefed.social 8 months ago
Yeah, too often Forbes will publish any old trash.
But it's hard to argue with maths.
lvxferre@mander.xyz 8 months ago
Good catch - I didn’t pay attention to the fact that it’s a contributor post. Even then, I believe it to be still exposing the “Reddit is junk stock” (implied: “don’t buy it!”) discourse to potential investors. The title alone already does it, for those who skip past the article.
ininewcrow@lemmy.ca 8 months ago
Great piece of marketing to have someone write the article, have people talk about it mistakenly as an actual Forbes article and drive interest in the stock that many clueless individuals will suddenly have an interest in Reddit Stock.
News is news … any news whether good or bad is good news for the company pushing their name.
Chances are … it was Reddit company marketers that set up this article to be featured on the Forbes website to drive attention to their company and their upcoming IPO.