Comment on One thing the fandoms can agree on.
Riccosuave@lemmy.world 1 year ago
I also don’t want Rian Johnson or Kathleen Kennedy anywhere near Star Wars or Star Trek. Add them to the list as well.
Comment on One thing the fandoms can agree on.
Riccosuave@lemmy.world 1 year ago
I also don’t want Rian Johnson or Kathleen Kennedy anywhere near Star Wars or Star Trek. Add them to the list as well.
Satelllliiiiiiiteeee@kbin.social 1 year ago
I'd be happy if Rian Johnson got another chance with Star Wars. Brick, Brothers Bloom, Looper, and Knives Out were all great and at least personally The Last Jedi felt like it was trying to set up things to pay off in the next movie since he was originally slated to write and direct Episode 8 and 9.
Riccosuave@lemmy.world 1 year ago
You’re entitled to your opinion, but I certainly don’t share it. I have never been as disappointed by any movie I have ever seen. I literally hate every single thing about it.
wjrii@kbin.social 1 year ago
I left it absolutely invigorated and optimistic for the franchise. I saw it had some flaws, with one sizeable one being that it should have ignored the cliffhanger in TFA and caught up 6-12 months later*; the OT (and less successfully, the PT) got to handwave a LOT of character development by simply letting life happen offscreen. Still, TLJ took a needlessly derivative setup from TFA and set the stage for a much more interesting Episode Nine than we got, and I utterly disagree that he didn't get or like Star Wars. Shit, Rian Johnson is the only one who was willing to SAY the words "Darth Sidious."
I thought he gave a thoughtful fan's perspective on what Star Wars needs to be to remain relevant, the theme of growing from failure being particularly well done for a big popcorn franchise. The scene with Rose's sister, the Yoda scene, the acting from Adam Driver after the throne room scene? All peak Star Wars IMHO. Then of course TROS came along and was so clumsy and petty in how it blew up Rian Johnson's new directions, and so generally messy, that it didn't even please the people who hated TLJ.
*-Two others being the framing device of the "slow speed chase" and Finn's arc being such a minor step forward . A few tweaks to the technobabble or moving them to Crait earlier and having it be a bit more of a formidable facility could have helped the first one, and having Finn more explicitly trying to save Rey and Poe at the cost of the Resistance might have better highlighted the additional layer of growth RJ was thought he still needed.