Comment on Goodbye Youtube and thanks for all the fish

• thatsnothowyoudoit@lemmy.ca ⁨1⁩ ⁨year⁩ ago

  As a former Nebula subscriber, here’s my hot take: it also has no real community and no chance for exposure to the up-and-comer (IE no way to breakout since it seems invite only?)

  I’ve found so many great YouTube channels filled with deep experience and expertise before they “catch on” (and some never “catch on”). The ability to find the small, powerful voice who’s just trying to share knowledge…

  I’m not defending YouTube/Alphabet here (as a company they’re no better than any other), I just think Nebula isn’t a great alternative and unless things change, can never be. It’s a walled garden in too many ways (paywall/creator invitations).

  In the year I had it I mostly watched the same videos on YouTube. If they were technical enough there was valuable discussion attached to the video; on Nebula that’s not the case and not possible. Even if it was possible I can’t imagine people fragmenting their discussion spaces between YouTube and closed-ecosystem like Nebula.

  Don’t even get me started with their (Nebula) inability to build a video queue -> wasting time and space on a poorly thought-out implementation of Autoplay was a terrible decision that further pushed me off the platform.

  It’s sad, I really wanted to like it. But I voted with my dollars and left.

  source

  • grozzle@lemm.ee ⁨1⁩ ⁨year⁩ ago

    (am the same person you replied to)

    i actually don’t disagree much with your points. i still watch most of the videos posted on both platforms on youtube, not Nebula, tbh.

    for me it’s mostly because Nebula haven’t made an official Kodi addon yet, and the unofficial one (by slyguy) often has buffering issues (which i don’t blame on slyguy).

    i sometimes “fake watch” good videos again on the nebula website to help that creator boost their revenue share of my subscription. a very clumsy hack.

    all that said - i am very glad that the videomakers i follow seem happy with Nebula, and since they say it’s helping them make better videos, i will continue to subscribe.

    i don’t know about the ‘invite only’ thing. i have recommended in yt comments to a couple of people i often watch (Joe Blogs is one, i think also Our Own Devices, DiodeGoneWild, perhaps also Denys Davydof and/or Jake Broe) that they should ask about joining, but i assume my messages weren’t seen, in the depths of yt comments. as for if it’s easy for new creators to join, again don’t know for sure but there seem to be some regular Neb uploaders without much/any yt presence.

    source

    • thatsnothowyoudoit@lemmy.ca ⁨1⁩ ⁨year⁩ ago

      Thanks for engaging!

      I should comment on my poorly phrased use of “invite only” -> I mean that from the creators’ perspective in case I fumbled that one. IE, I can’t just decide to share on Nebula, I have to be invited (seemingly by the creator personally? Ref: theverge.com/…/nebula-youtube-creator-business-fu…).

      source