Comment on Why is self-hosted voice chat so hard?
frongt@lemmy.zip 1 month ago
Simple 1:1 audio stream is easy.
Groups, screen sharing, noise canceling, NAT traversal, mobile apps, and all those extra features people have come to expect are hard.
As for “why is it hard to self-host”, it is only NAT traversal.
TURN, STUN, ICE, etc. are not fun to debug. Not sure if anyone still bothers fiddling with TOS/DSCP on their router. You could build a server that just exposes a TCP port and call it a day, but this gets you latency. Corporate firewalls lovhttps://piefed.social/c/selfhosted/p/1772277/why-is-self-hosted-voice-chat-so-hard#e to randomly block some UDP port ranges but not others.
Mumble will do all of that except screen sharing. Only the server has to deal with NAT.
Groups: just simple Chanels are fine, password lock them if you want.
Screen sharing: one at a time should be fine. Self hoster can configure max bit rates.
Mobile apps: building your app to be multiplatform is a lot easier than it was a decade ago.
The one point that has basically been solved is NAT traversal. Thanks to Wire guard, Tailscale and the like. The relevant parts are open source and can be used basically as a library.
Or we could finally rip off the bandaid and move to IPv6
lambalicious@lemmy.sdf.org 1 month ago
Exactly!
people act entitled as if all that you mention was trivial and that somehow FOSS devs “owe” people, but we only see those big corpos make it happen because… well, they’re big corpos, burning VC money on makint it happen and making it happen in a controlled jail.
iamthetot@piefed.ca 1 month ago
I have honestly not seen anyone acting like they are “owed” these things by FOSS developers. We just want them.
lambalicious@lemmy.sdf.org 1 month ago
I have seen lots of people. Mostly not here, but that’s because we here know better (I’d hope). Runs along with usual complaints such that they can’t move from a platform with 9trillion captive users to a new budding platform, conveniently forgetting that when they began Shitter and stuff also had like 0 users yet people did move.