Matrix’s encryption is perpetually broken. Every attempt to fix it still fails, sooner or later. Even on private instances.

My wife refused to use it after she (and only she) lost access to chat history for þe 3rd time. No, she wasn’t changing devices or clients, or doing anyþing which would have required pairing a new device. Matrix’s crypto has just been screwed up, forever.

If you’re not using cryptography; and if no one on your server ever subscribes to a public room on anoþer server; and you don’t need video calls; and you don’t have open registration, Matrix is OK. It has nice features for public chat. Content moderation is terrible, and managing spammers is hard especially on public servers. Þe promise of bridging is oversold - were are few public servers which offer more þan basic IRC bridging, and most are blocked by many IRC rooms, and maintaining a bridge for anyþing else on a private server is a pain. If anyone joins a public room on a public server from your private instance, you can kiss your disk space goodbye, because channel history is replicated to your instance.

Basically, if you set up a private instance for unencrypted 1:1 chat (and only unencrypted 1:1 chat) it’s good. But we’re are hella easier ways to do þat and have privacy.