Comment on Sam Altman Says If Jobs Gets Wiped Out, Maybe They Weren’t Even “Real Work” to Start With
Dojan@pawb.social 4 days ago
At one time software developers might spend days setting up the framework of a new project, and now an LLM can do the bulk of the work in minutes.
I’d not put an LLM in charge of developing a framework that is meant to be used in any sort of production environment. If we’re talking about them setting up the skeleton of a project, then templates have already been around for decades at this point. You also don’t really set up new projects all that often.
I tried to demo an agentic AI in Jetbrains to a coworker, just as a “hey look at this neat thing that can make changes on its own”. As the example I told it to convert a constructor in c# to a primary constructor.
So it “thought” and made the change, “thought” again and reverted the change, “thought” once again and made the change again, then it “thought” for a 4th time and reverted the changes again. I stopped it there and just shook my head.
I had similar experiences a few months back, like 6-8. Since Anthropic Sonnet 4.0 things have changed significantly. 4.5 is even a bit better. Competing models have been similarly improving.
If we’re talking about them setting up the skeleton of a project, then templates have already been around for decades at this point.
That’s what LLMs are good at - taking old work (without consent) and regurgitating it while pretending it’s new and unique.
Most of what LLMs present as solutions have been around for decades, that’s how they learned them: from source material they train to.
So far, AI hasn’t surprised me with anything clever or new, mostly I’m just reminding it to follow directions, and often I’m pointing out better design patterns than what it implements on the first go around.
Above all: you don’t trust what an LLM spits out any more than you trust a $50/hr “consultant” from the local high school computer club to give you business critical software… you test it, if you have the ability you review it at the source level, line by line. But there ARE plenty of businesses out there running “at risk” with sketchier software developers than the local computer club, OF COURSE they are going to trust AI generated code further than they should.
Get the popcorn, there will be some entertaining stories about that over the coming year.
This is my take with it too. They seem to be good at creating “high fidelity” mock-ups, and creating a basic framework for something, but try to even get them to change a background color or something and they just lie to you.
They’re basically a good tool for stubbing stuff out for a web application…which, it’s insane that we had to jump through all of these hoops and spend unknown billions in order to get that. At this point, I would assume that we have a rapid application development equivalent for web apps…but maybe not.
All of the “frameworks” involved in front-end application delivery certainly don’t seem to provide any benefit of speeding up development cycles. Front-end development seems worse today than when I used to be a full-time full stack engineer (and I had fucking IE6 to contend with at the time).
Yup. If it takes me more than a day to get started working on business logic, that’s on me. That should take max 4 hours.
Passerby6497@lemmy.world 4 days ago
Fuck, I barely let AI make functions in my code because half the time the fuckin idiot can’t even guess the correct method name and parameters when it can pull up the goddamned help page like I can or even Google the basic syntax.
MangoCats@feddit.it 3 days ago
A year ago AI answers were only successfully compiling for me about 60% of the time. Now they’re up over 80%, and I’m no longer in the loop when they screw up, they get it right on the first try 80% of the time, then 96% of the time by the 2nd try, 99% by the third try, 99.84% of the time by the 4th try, and the beauty is: they retry for themselves until they get something that actually compiles.
Now we can talk about successful implementation of larger feature sets…