Comment on Looking for recommendations for a multi home NAS solution

truthfultemporarily@feddit.org ⁨2⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

• Bubs@lemmy.zip ⁨2⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

  Those are good points to clear up.

  • At this point, 2 houses, but likely 3 by next year.
  • The first two will be a short drive away, but the third will be hours away.
  • The houses are on 100/50Mb fiber. Very stable internet.
  • Me being the tech person, I’ll access them every way that’s available. For the rest of my family I’ll set them up either with a hardwire or local network.
  • We will be using them as part of a 3-2-1 backup for all of our files like photos or documents. I’ll be using the second drive for occasional video backup storage.
  • The shared drive will probably be 5-10 TB, depending on how much storage each household wants. The second drive for me will be around 20TB.

  source

  • truthfultemporarily@feddit.org ⁨2⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

    So I think this can be achieved in different levels of complexity.

    First of all, you may want to look into ZFS, because there you can have multiple “partitions” that all have access to the entire free space of the device or devices, meaning you won’t need two separate drives. Or probably you want multiple smaller and cheaper devices that are combined together because it will be cheaper and more fault tolerant.

    You also need some way to actually access the data. You have not shared how that is supposed to work: smb/nfs, etc. In either case you need a software that can do that. There a various options.

    Then, you probably want to create some form of overlay network. This will make it so that the individual devices can talk to each other lime they are in the same lan. You could use tailscale/headscale for this. If you have static public IPs you can probably get around this and build your own mesh using wireguard (spoiler: thats what tailscale does anyway).

    Then, the syncing. You can try to use syncthing for this, but I am not sure it will work well in this scenario.

    The better solution is to use a distributed storage system like garage for this, but that requires some technical expertise. garagehq.deuxfleurs.fr

    Garage would actually allow you to for example only store two copies, so with three locations you would actually gain some storage space. Or you stay with the 3x replication factor. Anyway, garage is an object store which backup software will absolutely support, but there is no easy NFS/smb. So your smart TV, vanilla windows or whatever will not be able to access it.

    Overall its a pretty tricky thing that will require some managing. There is no super easy solution to set this up.

    source
• 11111one11111@lemmy.world ⁨2⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

  Not open but here for info of similar situation I’ve thought about doing. So

  • how many houses

  Between 3-5

  • how far are they apart (latency)

  Different towns for 1-3 houses and same road for 3 houses, including mine where NAS would be. So im assuming this is some cloud sharing thing but im looking to host it and not use Google photos anymore.

  • what is their internet connection like?

  Everyone has high speed i think. 1gb/s I think.

  • up/downstream?

  Always pee downstream. Idk what this is asking. Sorry

  • Static IP? Is it stable?

  Yes to both but would like it to be accessible on mobile devices too.

  • how are they supposed to access the data?

  Just looking for info on what to learn so whatever you recommend lol

  • what kind of data is it, and what is the access pattern? Meaning, is it text files? Occasional pictures? Movies?

  Prolly 90% pictures & 10% video

  • how much data do you need in total (yours+others)

  Shit idk enough to cover 3 families with multiple crotch fruit under 3 years old so 50,000TB+ range.

  source