isleepinahammock
@isleepinahammock@lemmy.blahaj.zone
- Comment on Things you feel Star Trek handle poorly? (In general, political, technical, etc, share your opinion) 2 weeks ago:
Honestly, the whole thermodynamics of the Starship Enterprise are an open question. Real spaceships need to be festooned with radiator panels. The Federation ships just deal with waste heat by venting it…somewhere? So it has to have some thermal management system that is beyond our understanding. How that would affect how long a passively cooling starship would take to cool down, I cannot say.
- Comment on Things you feel Star Trek handle poorly? (In general, political, technical, etc, share your opinion) 2 weeks ago:
That’s true. If you assume it’s a lot more than just the O2 supply, it makes more sense. Ok. I have a new fun headcanon.
So, here’s the thing. We know the Federation has multiple species in it. Those species likely have different atmospheric requirements. Sure, we sometimes see crew members wearing breathing apparatus, like the Benzites. But I wonder if every species actually needs its own atmospheric mix? Maybe every species has its own ideal mixture of oxygen, nitrogen, CO2, etc.
That is a problem if everyone has to share the same atmosphere. But what if they didn’t have to? Imagine if the life support system is generating little individual micro atmospheric pockets for every person onboard. Every crew member basically gets to breathe the atmospheric mix of their home planet. Using transporters, force fields, replicators, and good-old-fashioned fans, the ship generates little atmospheric bubbles around each crew member. And those bubbles move with them through the ship.
So would anyone need a breathing apparatus? It’s possible those species just have very unique air requirements that go beyond the capabilities of the life support system to handle. For example, maybe the Benzites require a gas that is poisonous to some other species? You don’t want to make big pockets of that floating around. You minimize the amount of it introduced to the ship by using personal breathing devices.
This would also explain why the system is capable of dispersing arbitrary compounds.
But the need for constant filtration is an interesting point as well. Though that seems like less of an immediately lethal threat than a long-term exposure thing.
- Comment on Things you feel Star Trek handle poorly? (In general, political, technical, etc, share your opinion) 2 weeks ago:
Life support. It’s always hilarious to me when power going out to life support is treated as an instantly fatal threat. IIRC, if you actually do the calculation it’s ridiculous. If you combine the interior volume of the Enterprise D with its crew count, you would find that the life support system could be offline for MONTHS before the oxygen levels started to substantially drop.
- Comment on 3D printing a house 2 months ago:
Eh, some can be recycled up to ten times. And it’s not like you can use plywood forms infinitely either. Those break down after 10-20 uses as well on average. And, just like plastic, every time you reuse plywood molds some of the material gets lost. Some gets damaged when prying the forms off. Plywood sheets get cut down to the shape of the next job. Etc.
And again, I’m imagining this primarily where plywood forms are not practical without very skilled and intricate work. Imagine a home built like this. The cost would be completely impractical for normal residential budgets. But printed forms and injected concrete? Maybe.
- Comment on 3D printing a house 2 months ago:
Exactly. Automated house building could take many forms. It could be a big 3D concrete printer on a gantry crane. It could be a crew of humanoid robots using ordinary human power tools. It could be a robot arm on a powered dolly that lifts and nails, glues, or welds panels and beams into place.
- Comment on 3D printing a house 2 months ago:
That would be a lot of waste plastic.
I wouldn’t think so. This may be one of the few cases where recycling plastic is actually practical. Recycling plastic is normally a big problem because it’s a very dirty supply stream. Plastic products often have multiple types of plastic laminated together, often include plastic labeling, etc. Even if you make a plastic consumer good out of a reusable thermoplastic, recycling is still impractical. Plus the main contaminants - food remains, react chemically at the temperatures necessary to remelt the plastic.
But this? You would be printing out huge slabs of solid plastic. Imagine big blocks and slabs of plastic 3"-12" thick. They could be made entirely of a single type of plastic. You use a thermoplastic, one that can be melted and reused repeatedly. Make them with no dyes and a chemistry optimized for maximum recyclability.
The printer prints out big plastic forms. Then the forms are injection-filled with concrete. Workers then pry or chip off the plastic forms and collect the debris for recycling. At the recycling plant, the pieces are given a basic cleaning, but the contaminants are almost entirely bits of concrete. Plastic melts at a temperature far far below the melting or decomposition point of any of concrete’s components. Concrete dust can simply be filtered out from the stream of molten plastic.
And that is a lot of plastic on one job. But because of that, builders would actually be incentivized to recycle it. You’re talking potentially thousands of dollars worth of plastic sitting there.
This wouldn’t be a practical replacement for regular rectangular concrete formwork. If you just want straight vertical walls and floors, since you have to tear-down the dorms afterwards, this isn’t going to be competitive with regular formwork. But what if you want to live in a curvy house? What if you want a more flowing space with continuously varying arches, curves, and vaults? This kind of almost organic home form is not within the budget of the average person. The forms required are just too complex. For this type of organic modern architecture, I could see 3D printing plastic forms being a practical option.
You’re right, it would require a lot of plastic. But existing concrete forms also require a lot of material. We’re just able to reuse the forms many times.