!politics@piefed.social
Any politics anywhere in the world. Inevitably it’ll be 99% US stuff, but that’s not a rule.
This community works differently to how most politics communities work. It has strict rules designed to facilitate productive discussion. You can be rude, to a point, but you can’t participate in bad faith:
- If you claim someone said something they didn’t say, that’s a temp ban.
- If you make a factual claim but then aren’t interested in backing it up, that’s a temp ban.
- If you’re asked one or two reasonable questions about what you said, and you’re still talking but you’re pretending the questions didn’t happen or rejecting the premise of answering them, that’s a temp ban.
The idea is to make the discussion productive. Let’s see how it works. Maybe this is a fool’s errand but IDK how any set of moderation could be worse than lemmy.world.
Other misc rules:
- Reliable sources only.
- Keep it productive please.
- Self posts for discussion are fine. This includes videos or photos. No meme posts or screenshots please.
- No personal insults.
- No racism / transphobia / related bigotry.
Blaze@lemmy.zip 3 weeks ago
First of all, good luck for that, it’s going to be something.
Second, when it’s still in it’s early stages, would it be possible to call it !uspolitics@piefed.social instead so that
It seems like a good opportunity to avoid the !politics@lemmy.world issue which is explicitly about politics
PhilipTheBucket@piefed.social 3 weeks ago
Oh, I didn’t realize it was going to make a public post about it before I had a chance to populate it lol.
Hm. I’ll defer to @rimu@piefed.social about the naming. To me, “politics” while allowing politics from any country is fine, but I’m American so maybe that is just my exceptionalism. I generally follow the Beehaw conventions, they seem to strike a really good balance of short concise names without being overly chauvinistic about it.
rimu@piefed.social 3 weeks ago
Naah I can’t be policing the naming of communities, really. Seems a bit micro-managing, when it’s somewhat of a grey area.
So while I agree with Blaze I’m not going to enforce anything about it.
IMO politics is generally pretty nationally-focused and most of the time the significance of each turn of the worm is only really obvious to people in that country. e.g. I’m pretty up with the play on all the anglosphere politics but am incompetent when it comes to south african or indian or slovakian politics and that’s fine by me. There is some globally-significant politics news but maybe not enough to sustain a community on it. So a collapse into US politics news is probably inevitable.
How about we have two politics communities, one for US and one for everything else? i.e. Keep the existing one and just change it’s description and make a second one.
Also as Blaze said there are other PieFed instances. I’m a fan of !world@quokk.au but feddit.online or piefed.zip are good homes too.
Blaze@lemmy.zip 3 weeks ago
Why do you want to refer to Rimu about the name, while you didn’t consult him in the first place to create this community?
If you are looking for precedent on other instances, there is !AskUSA@discuss.online and !casualeurope@piefed.social who clearly scope their demographics.
Beehaw has !usnews@beehaw.org
I just feel like if want it to be worldwide, you will see people post politics from any country in the world, then people not interested in those politics won’t see how it’s relevant to them, thus hindering the success of the community. Also, it wouldn’t be a similarly-scope community compared to !politics@lemmy.world, so people will probably stay on it (and non-Americans will also prefer it, as it allows them to block US politics in one community without blocking themselves from the rest of the world)
Beehaw also has a much smaller audience, if your community ever get popular, you will see a lot of content.
Skavau@piefed.social 3 weeks ago
Well you can make use of the Piefed tagging system to distinguish different locations or topics etc
Skavau@piefed.social 3 weeks ago
Isn’t this effectively suggesting to delete the community and remake as US Politics?
Blaze@lemmy.zip 3 weeks ago
Yes. I guess it depends what the scope @PhilipTheBucket@ponder.cat wants to target it