Comment on The ACLU Fights for Your Constitutional Right to Make Deepfakes

<- View Parent
hedgehog@ttrpg.network ⁨3⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

ACLU, is this really that high a priority in the list of rights we need to fight for right now?

You say this like the ACLU isn’t doing a ton of other things at the same time. Here are their 2024 plans, for example. See also www.aclu.org/news

Besides that, these laws are being passed now, and they’re being passed by people who have no clue what they’re talking about. It wouldn’t make sense for them to wait until the laws are passed to challenge them rather than lobbying to prevent them from being passed in the first place.

wouldn’t these arguments fall apart under the lens of slander?

If you disseminate a deepfake with slanderous intent then your actions are likely already illegal under existing laws, yes, and that’s exactly the point. The ACLU is opposing new laws that are over-broad. There are gaps in the laws, and we should fill those gaps, but not at the expense of infringing upon free speech.

source
Sort:hotnewtop