Comment on Security and docker
possiblylinux127@lemmy.zip 3 months agoI think speculation is generally a bad security practice. What you need is least privilege and security in depth. At some point you need to trust something somewhere. Kernel level exploits are very rare
I think assuming that you are safe because you aren’t aware of any vulnerabilities is bad security practice.
Minimizing your attack surface is critical. Defense in depth is just one way to minimize your attack surface (but a very effective one). Putting your container inside a VM is excellent defense in depth. Putting your container inside a non-root user barely is because you still have one Linux kernel sized hole in your swiss-cheese defence model.
How is the Linux kernel more insecure than anything else? It isn’t this massive gapping hole like you make it sound. In 20 years how many serious organization destroying vulnerabilities have there been? It is pretty solid.
I guess we should all use whatever proprietary software thing you think is best
The Linux kernel is less secure for running untrusted software than a VM because most hypervisors have a far smaller attack surface.
how many serious organization destroying vulnerabilities have there been? It is pretty solid.
The CVEs differ? The reasons that most organizations don’t get destroyed is that they don’t run untrusted software on the same kernels that process their sensitive information.
whatever proprietary software thing you think is best
This is a ridiculous attack. I never suggested anything about proprietary software. Linux’s KVM is pretty great.
Lemongrab@lemmy.one 3 months ago
It is not speculation, it is reducing attack surface. Security is preemptive. Docker/Podman are not strong isolation solutions. Rare does not mean we shouldn’t protect against the chance of kernel vulnerabilities. The linux kernel around 30 million lines of code long and written in a memory unsafe language. Code isn’t safe just because we dont know the vulnerabilities, this is basic cybersec reasoning.
possiblylinux127@lemmy.zip 3 months ago
Write me an exploit then
If it so insecure prove it
Lemongrab@lemmy.one 3 months ago
That is not how security works. You must protect against known and unknown attack vectors. I am only pointing out weaknesses of Docker and other linux containers that share the kernel with the host or/and run with Root. I’m not saying anything original or crazy, just read up on the security of these technologies and their limits. I am not a malware designer, I am a security researcher.
Look into gVisor and Kara Containers for info on how to improve the security of containers.
Here are some readings for you:
…tux.pizza/…/help_can_i_safely_run_malware_inside…
csoonline.com/…/vulnerabilities-in-docker-other-c…
www.panoptica.app/…/7-ways-to-escape-a-container
blog.trailofbits.com/…/understanding-docker-conta…
securityweek.com/leaky-vessels-container-escape-v…
cybereason.com/…/container-escape-all-you-need-is…