Comment on Hogwarts Legacy has officially cleared Zelda as 2023's best-selling game worldwide

• ramble81@lemm.ee ⁨9⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

  (Thought experiment time) So at what point, if ever, does a universe separate from its creator? Think about Star Wars. There have been a large number of derivative works by multiple authors. However if George Lucas came out against gays and trans people, would you taint the entire franchise? At what point are the two separated, if ever?

  source

  • LinkOpensChest_wav@lemmy.dbzer0.com ⁨9⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

    However if George Lucas came out against gays and trans people, would you taint the entire franchise?

    Yes. I would immediately lose ibr interest in Star Wars and go do something else. There’s plenty of entertainment out there that’s not made by shitty bigots.

    source

    • Vespair@lemm.ee ⁨9⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

      Fr, why are we acting like this is hard? Or acting like any of these aggressively mid media franchises are so sacred as to be unassailable?

      Even if JKR was a literal saint Harry Potter would still be Baby’s First Fantasy Series, at best, so the idea that so many people are willing to continually enrich one of the world’s most influential TERFs for it honestly blows my fucking mind.

      Like just pick and follow literally any other fantasy series folks, jesus.

      source
  • Devccoon@lemmy.world ⁨9⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

    Star Wars is an awkward example because it’s already pretty well tainted itself with mediocre films.

    But yes, unironically I would actively stop looking for the shreds of good among the carnage that is the once-beloved franchise if I knew its creator, whose name is still tied to it and who financially benefits at least from the propagation of successful entries under that IP, would be just a little bit more able to get their awful views out there thanks to that success.

    source
  • wildginger@lemmy.myserv.one ⁨9⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

    When it stops making them rich as fuck

    source
• DadVolante@sh.itjust.works ⁨9⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

  This happens a lot more than you think. It isn’t just coping.

  How many movies were produced by Weinstein? How many comics were published by bigots that still re-sell 8n droves today?

  Wrestlemania season is here. THAT company is completely vile from the ground up.

  Sometimes, people just pick and choose their fiction and legitimately separate the artist from the art. The Harry Potter franchise has outgrown it’s original author, just like Star Wars, Lord of the Rings, Star Trek, or almost any franchise.

  If you think the world truly is so black and white, you haven’t gone out and experienced enough of it.

  source

  • wildginger@lemmy.myserv.one ⁨9⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

    Thats not death of the author, thats you covering your eyes while handing them money.

    Death of the author does not exist while the author makes money off the product.

    If you pirated the hogwarts game? Then you have room to speak on death of the author. But jkr has a hefty royalties deal on hp products. If you paid for it, the author is living well.

    Im sorry you apparently cant face that truth, but that doesnt change it.

    source

    • DadVolante@sh.itjust.works ⁨9⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

      Bruh, if you are going to try and pretend your consumption under capitalism is better than the other, that’s cool.

      I’m sure you are the most morally sound person you’ve ever met 🤣

      source

      • wildginger@lemmy.myserv.one ⁨9⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

        The phrase “there is no ethical consumption under capitalism” does not mean “therefore, death of the author always exists for all art the second it is made.”

        For starters, you will not die if you dont experience all art made. Its not food. Its not shelter. You will be okay if you dont watch some movies, dont read some books, and dont play some games. I promise.

        But, more specifically, death of the author means to separate an author and their life from the work they create. If your purchase directly funds the author? You didnt separate the author from the work.

        Death of the author is when you accept and understand that reading a story written by a shitheel from the 18th century is not supporting their shitheel opinions. That you can study the work and its influence on culture without that study or consumption being explicit or implicit support of the creators thoughts and opinions.

        But when you pay an author for their work, you have supported the author. Period, thats what the word means.

        Now you can fibble or quibble about morality of putting money into someones pocket all you like, but if the author is literally benefiting from your purchase, they are not dead. There has been no death of author.

        source

        • -> View More Comments
• TwilightVulpine@lemmy.world ⁨9⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

  So very true.

  HP Lovecraft was horribly racist, but his works are in the Public Domain. Neither him, his estate or any causes he supported get any money by engaging with his works. His opinions are still part of his works, but that can be criticized and modified in adaptations and derivative works.

  The same can’t be said of living creators who still own and profit from those works. Even if some team deliberately tries to gloss over or alter concerning aspects, the money the author gets might still be directed towards concerning movements.

  In all fairness there are concerning aspects in many industries and a lot that we consume, and each person has a lot of other issues to worry about, so while disappointing, it’s inevitable that people won’t care about everything. But I definitely don’t feel confortable giving money to someone who’s spreading hate about people I care for. I used to be a big HP fan but this situation completely spoiled any interest I had in that world… and also helped me realize it was never that good anyway.

  source