Comment on Thermostats compatible with selfhosted Home Assistant

• eightys3v3n@lemmy.ca ⁨2⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

  Well Thread allows devices to require internet connectivity to pair. It also allows devices to fetch firmware updates from the manufacturer. And it allows features to be locked to their specific app. Thread and Matter are more complex to setup self-hosted style; it makes no difference when you use official hubs though. Thread doesn’t have many device types and manufacturers available.

  Zigbee does not require or work over the internet, no trust required. It is very easy to setup self-hosted. There is a Zigbee everything made by everyone from large companies to random brandless places.

  Zigbee is my preference as a result of the internet connectivity requirement. I do not trust random manufacturers to not brick my devices when they go out of business or choose to release a competing product.

  source

  • PeriodicallyPedantic@lemmy.ca ⁨2⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

    Well that leaves me with mixed feelings.

    Thread itself doesn’t need Internet connectivity, but thread seems to almost always be paired with matter, which does (during provisioning).

    I like that matter provisioning requires verification of their certificate, but I don’t like that certificates can expire or the certificate authority can shut down. Although maybe that’s all taken care of by the DCL? In which case that’d be fine.

    source

    • eightys3v3n@lemmy.ca ⁨2⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

      In theory, Home Assistant could also give users the option to ignore certificate checks.

      I also haven’t seen specific details on whether Home Assistant’s implementation allows sensors to contact the internet by default or what setting changes this.

      It’s just foggier and less user focused by design in my opinion. But as one would expect when Google and other large corporations were the ones to develop it,

      source