Comment on Keir Starmer abandons plans for compulsory digital ID
Denjin@feddit.uk 4 days ago
Is there any major Labour policy that hasn’t been U-turned on?
I genuinely don’t understand everyone complaining about u-turns. Setting aside that this isn’t really a u-turn, they’re still doing it, just won’t be mandatory.
Would you rather a government that dogmatically sticks to every single idea they have regardless of public opinion, or a government that changes its policies in response to feedback?
My issue is the government coming up with ideas that everyone can see from the outset are doomed to fail, for seemingly arbritray reasons, and then rolling them back when the inevitable happens.
Winter fuel being the most glaring: we need to show the banks we’re fiscally responsible, we then have no material change in how the banks view the government but have a minor shift in the forecasts for 5 years time, we’ve done it, we’re fiscally responsible now so pensioners can have their £500 back.
Yeah, I’d rather they did better in the first place too. But I’m not going to complain when they finally do the right thing. That’s just going to lead to them not changing unpopular policies at all.
Since 2008 the banks themselves have had to prove they are fiscally responsible which I very doubt they are.
Support of genocide?
They publicly condemned Israel, committed to arresting Netanyahu if he ever came here, sanctioned much of the Israeli parliament, refused to join the US/Israel in attacking Iran, ramped up humanitarian aid for Palestine, stopped weapons exports to Israel, and formally recognised Palestine.
I struggle to see this rabid support of Israel that Lemmy posters always seem to talk about.
Nope. They publicly supported Israeli “right” to starve Gaza, criminalised the support of a direct action group that opposes the genocide, continue to arm Israel, allowed Israel to attack British boats and kidnap British citizens sailing on them, continue to fly spy planes for Israel and refuel their planes at Akrotiri.
The UK government is complicit in genocide.
criminalised the support of a direct action group that opposes the genocide,
No. They proscribed a group that ram raided factories with workers inside, advocated for genocide, trashed businesses for having Jewish owners, smashed a policewoman’s back while she was incapacitated on the floor with a sledgehammer, and broke into an RAF base and destroyed the engines of two jets.
allowed Israel to attack British boats and kidnap British citizens
More bullshit
continue to fly spy planes for Israel
They warned Israel against targeting civilians and gave them information on Hamas installations in an attempt to lessen civilian casualties.
and refuel their planes at Akrotiri
Stop fucking lying. Israel and the UK don’t even have compatible fueling systems.
The UK government is complicit in genocide.
If you believe that, you are brain-dead. Re-read the above comment.
Support for Brexit.
They did not support Brexit.
Could have fooled me…
I don’t see how. Starmer is getting closer to the EU.
towerful@programming.dev 4 days ago
I’d rather they u-turned shitty ideas than waffle-stomp them through.
How the fuck the OSA seemed to just drift through is astounding
TheGrandNagus@lemmy.world 4 days ago
Because unfortunately, all our politicians want it, and the public wants it too.
Reddit and Lemmy are very much in the minority on OSA.
Which is a shame, because I find the OSA to be stupid and unworkable.