No, the use of words matter when having a debate. "Theft" is an emotionally charged word that has a lot of implications that don't actually map well to what's going on here. It's not a good word to be using for this.
Seems to map pretty well. I’ve looked up a handful of definitions of theft and looking at it from an emotionless perspective it seems to fit. To take something without permission or the right to. I don’t really see where the removal of a finite resource is required.
When you steal something the person you stole it from doesn't have it any more. That's why copyright violation is covered by an entirely different set of laws from theft.
This isn't even copying, really, since the end result is not the same as anything in the source material.
Lots of people may want it to be illegal, may want to call it theft, but that won't make it so when they take it to court.
“When you steal something the person you stole it from doesn’t have it any more.”
That may be the case from a legal perspective, but it’s not in the actual definition of the word. Illegal or not, it does seem to be stealing. Like I said I don’t see a requirement for the thing being stolen to be a singular, finite thing.
FaceDeer@kbin.social 9 months ago
No, the use of words matter when having a debate. "Theft" is an emotionally charged word that has a lot of implications that don't actually map well to what's going on here. It's not a good word to be using for this.
EncryptKeeper@lemmy.world 9 months ago
Seems to map pretty well. I’ve looked up a handful of definitions of theft and looking at it from an emotionless perspective it seems to fit. To take something without permission or the right to. I don’t really see where the removal of a finite resource is required.
FaceDeer@kbin.social 9 months ago
When you steal something the person you stole it from doesn't have it any more. That's why copyright violation is covered by an entirely different set of laws from theft.
This isn't even copying, really, since the end result is not the same as anything in the source material.
Lots of people may want it to be illegal, may want to call it theft, but that won't make it so when they take it to court.
EncryptKeeper@lemmy.world 9 months ago
“When you steal something the person you stole it from doesn’t have it any more.”
That may be the case from a legal perspective, but it’s not in the actual definition of the word. Illegal or not, it does seem to be stealing. Like I said I don’t see a requirement for the thing being stolen to be a singular, finite thing.