Comment on Australians soon facing age checks when viewing adult websites
squigum@aussie.zone 13 hours agoJust watched it and yeah, that’s an even more depressing picture of how it was covered. The headlines I’d seen were:
“Social media age verification possible but laden with risks, landmark study warns” (ABC)
“Trial of tech that could be used to keep Australian under-16s off social media finds some errors ‘inevitable’” (Guardian)
Those stories at least didn’t just parrot the government’s spin - trouble is they made the study sound more sceptical/balanced than it is and didn’t question its credibility.
Nath@aussie.zone 12 hours ago
The irony for is I’m not entirely unsympathetic to the cause they’re pushing for this legislation. I don’t think Social Media access to kids is healthy. Hell, I don’t think Social Media access to adults is healthy. I remember when the web was read-only for morons. I’d love to go back to those days. Once any idiot could put their drivel online, they did.
I think some sort of online test/license would be a better solution. Show people the sorts of lights and shiny they’ll experience online. Teach them about misinformation. Teach them about verifying sources and checking websites for whether they are trustworthy. Give them an exam and if they pass, they can have a license to go online. Make everyone go through that and if you can pass it at 15, good luck to you. If you fail it at 50, sorry - the web stays read-only to you until you can get it through your thick skull that there are people out there who lie. Not everything you read is true.
Of course, this would probably be just as unpopular as the approach the government is taking. Eh. I don’t have all the answers.
squigum@aussie.zone 5 hours ago
Yep, I’m not against proper age checking as long as it’s developed carefully with a secure/private by design mentality, but this government’s self-imposed deadline and focus on ticking political boxes will effectively put consumer choice and privacy far below the interests of tech companies and age assurance industry investors. It’s looking like a familiar story - outsourcing responsibility for the practical implementation to questionable interests and promising “industry standards” and “safeguards” to protect consumers which are then poorly enforced or not practical to enforce. That’ll replicate the fundamental shortcomings of our privacy regulation more broadly which have made poor policies/practices and data breaches so routine.