weird, to be fair, my experience has been mostly with Amanita ocreata, the destroying angel - I’m not in Europe and I’ve never interacted with Amanita phalloides in particular.
Also most of the time I have interacted with them when they were mature fruits, I have found them when still in their volva, but I didn’t notice any difference in smell (or even notice if there was a lack of smell, etc.).
I suspect when cooking them, it could mask the smell and taste as well. Most of the deaths are from East Asian immigrants mistakenly assuming the mushrooms here are like the ones at home, and they mis-identify and then harvest & eat the Amanita spp. instead of what they thought they were harvesting (I actually don’t know the mushroom they mistake it for that is found in Asia).
The main risk of the Amanita spp. for me is just that i eat stinkhorn eggs and puff balls, and sometimes truffles - so it’s important to verify you aren’t digging up the early fruiting phase when the Amanita is still in the volva - but it’s easy to tell by cutting it open.
Ah A. Ocreata is actually reported to have a poor taste.
Most of the deaths are from East Asian immigrants mistakenly assuming the mushrooms here are like the ones at home, and they mis-identify and then harvest & eat the Amanita spp. instead of what they thought they were harvesting (I actually don’t know the mushroom they mistake it for that is found in Asia).
I’ve heard this factoid is pretty exaggerated, it’s not like East Asia doesn’t have both deadly and edible Amanitas
dandelion@lemmy.blahaj.zone 6 days ago
tbh they smell awful, I wouldn’t want to eat one
the_artic_one@programming.dev 5 days ago
They’re supposed to smell better when they’re young and they’re generally reported to taste good.
dandelion@lemmy.blahaj.zone 5 days ago
weird, to be fair, my experience has been mostly with Amanita ocreata, the destroying angel - I’m not in Europe and I’ve never interacted with Amanita phalloides in particular.
Also most of the time I have interacted with them when they were mature fruits, I have found them when still in their volva, but I didn’t notice any difference in smell (or even notice if there was a lack of smell, etc.).
I suspect when cooking them, it could mask the smell and taste as well. Most of the deaths are from East Asian immigrants mistakenly assuming the mushrooms here are like the ones at home, and they mis-identify and then harvest & eat the Amanita spp. instead of what they thought they were harvesting (I actually don’t know the mushroom they mistake it for that is found in Asia).
The main risk of the Amanita spp. for me is just that i eat stinkhorn eggs and puff balls, and sometimes truffles - so it’s important to verify you aren’t digging up the early fruiting phase when the Amanita is still in the volva - but it’s easy to tell by cutting it open.
the_artic_one@programming.dev 4 days ago
Ah A. Ocreata is actually reported to have a poor taste.
Image