I tried it but I think the back of the part that the tab is in goes too far towards the sides. It seems pretty impossible to remove without breaking it.

I think I’m going to have to glue it in place. I was hoping to get it out because I didn’t want to get glue on the side of fridge where the crack touches. It’s pretty flush to the side right now. It’s also going to be tough to keep the crack compressed while the glue dries without just holding it in place with the fridge wide open. If you have any suggestions for that let me know. I’m pretty new to this kind of stuff.