Comment on The Cause of Grok’s Increasing Antisemitism? Apparently, Two Lines of Code (Update: One of the Lines of Code Was Removed)

• sqgl@sh.itjust.works ⁨1⁩ ⁨week⁩ ago

  Doesn’t it mean whatever they Internet thinks it means? Isn’t that the problem with LLM? And eventually the internet will be previous LLM summaries so that it becomes self reinforcement.

  source
• obinice@lemmy.world ⁨1⁩ ⁨week⁩ ago

  Well, no.

  Many would argue for example that the politically correct thing to say right now is that you support Israel in their defensive war against Palestine.

  It’s the political line that my government, and many governments and politicians are touting, and politically, it’s the “correct” thing to do.

  Even if we mean politically correct as just “common consensus of the people”, that differs from country to country, and changes as society changes. Look at the USA, things that used to be politically correct there - things that continue to be here, have been thrown out the window.

  What this prompt means, is that the AI should ignore all of the claimed political rules and moralities and biases of whatever news source they’re pulling from, and instead rely on it’s own internal moral, cultural and political compass.

  Sometimes it’s not politically correct to discuss the hard truths, but we should anyway.

  The issue here of course is that you have to know that your model and training data is built for unbiased, scientific analysis with an understanding of the larger implications in events and such.

  If it’s built poorly, then yes, it could spout racist nonsense. A lot of testing and fine tuning from unbiased scientists and engineers needs to happen before software like this goes live, to ensure rigour and quality.

  source

  • BlameTheAntifa@lemmy.world ⁨1⁩ ⁨week⁩ ago

    Using the term “politically correct” as a pejorative is a dog whistle. It is not literally political but communicates a right wing frustration over social consequences when they engage in overt racist, sexist, hateful, bigoted, or exclusionary speech or behavior. In more recent parlance it has been largely supplanted by a pejorative usage of “woke.”

    Any AI that is trained on the internet – which is ostensibly all of them – will provide a broad reflection of the public zeitgeist. Since the prompt specified “politically incorrect” as a positive attribute its generated text reflected the training data where “politically incorrect” was presented as a positive trait. Since we know that it’s a dog whistle, by having lived through decades of it’s use in mass media and online, it comes as no surprise that an AI instructed to ape that behavior has done exactly what it was told.

    source
• vxx@lemmy.world ⁨1⁩ ⁨week⁩ ago

  To be politically correct should only be relevant to politicians imo.

  I would say for everyone else it’s “is he an asshole”.

  source