Comment on Judge Rules Training AI on Authors' Books Is Legal But Pirating Them Is Not

• booly@sh.itjust.works ⁨9⁩ ⁨minutes⁩ ago

  Does buying the book give you license to digitise it?

  Does owning a digital copy of the book give you license to convert it into another format and copy it into a database?

  Yes. That’s what the court ruled here. If you legally obtain a printed copy of a book you are free to digitize it or archive it for yourself. And you’re allowed to keep that digital copy, analyze and index it and search it, in your personal library.

  Anthropic’s practice of buying physical books, removing the bindings, scanning the pages, and digitizing the content while destroying the physical book was found to be legal, so long as Anthropic didn’t distribute that library outside of its own company.

  source
• VoterFrog@lemmy.world ⁨23⁩ ⁨hours⁩ ago

  It seems like a lot of people misunderstand copyright so let’s be clear: the answer is yes. You can absolutely digitize your books. You can rip your movies and store them on a home server and run them through compression algorithms.

  Copyright exists to prevent others from redistributing your work so as long as you’re doing all of that for personal use, the copyright owner has no say over what you do with it.

  You even have some degree of latitude to create and distribute works from those with a violation only occurring when you distribute something pretty damn close to a copy of the original. Some examples: create a word cloud of a book, analyze the tone of news article to help you trade stocks, produce an image containing the most prominent color in every frame of a movie, or create a search index of the words found on all websites on the internet.

  You can absolutely do the same kinds of things an AI does with a work as a human.

  source
• Enkimaru@lemmy.world ⁨1⁩ ⁨day⁩ ago

  You can digitize the books you own. You do not need a license for that. And of course you could put that digital format into a database. As databases are explicit exceptions from copyright law. If you want to go to the extreme: delete first copy. Then you have only in the database. However: AIs/LLMs are not based on data bases. But on neural networks. The original data gets lost when “learned”.

  source

  • nednobbins@lemmy.zip ⁨22⁩ ⁨hours⁩ ago

    If you want to go to the extreme: delete first copy.

    You can; as I understand it, the only legal requirement is that you only use one copy at a time.

    ie. I can give my book to a friend after I’m done reading it; I can make a copy of a book and keep them at home and at the office and switch off between reading them; I’m not allowed to make a copy of the book hand one to a friend and then both of us read it at the same time.

    source