Because LLMs operate at the token level, I think it would be a more fair comparison with humans to ask why humans can’t produce the IPA spelling words they can say, /nɔr kæn ðeɪ ˈizəli rid θɪŋz ˈrɪtən ˈpjʊrli ɪn aɪ pi ˈeɪ/ despite the fact that it should be simple to – they understand the sounds after all. I’d be impressed if somebody could do this too! But that most people can’t shouldn’t really move you to think humans must be fundamentally stupid because of this one curious artifact.
Comment on AGI achieved 🤖
UnderpantsWeevil@lemmy.world 3 days agoone should be impressed that the Chinese Room is so capable despite being a completely deterministic machine.
I’d be more impressed if the room could tell me how many "r"s are in Strawberry inside five minutes.
If one day we discover that the human brain works on much simpler principles
Human biology, famous for being simple and straightforward.
jsomae@lemmy.ml 3 days ago
UnderpantsWeevil@lemmy.world 2 days ago
why humans can’t produce the IPA spelling words they can say, /nɔr kæn ðeɪ ˈizəli rid θɪŋz ˈrɪtən ˈpjʊrli ɪn aɪ pi ˈeɪ/ despite the fact that it should be simple to – they understand the sounds after all
That’s just access to the right keyboard interface. Humans can and do produce those spellings with additional effort or advanced tool sets.
humans must be fundamentally stupid because of this one curious artifact.
Humans turns oatmeal into essays via a curios lump of muscle is an impressive enough trick on its face.
LLMs have 95% of the work of human intelligence handled for them and still stumble on the last bits.
jsomae@lemmy.ml 2 days ago
I mean, among people who are proficient with IPA, they still struggle to read whole sentences written entirely in IPA. Similarly, people who speak and read chinese struggle to read entire sentences written in pinyin. I’m not saying people can’t do it, just that it’s much less natural for us (even though it doesn’t really seem like it ought to be.)
UnderpantsWeevil@lemmy.world 2 days ago
Similarly, people who speak and read chinese struggle to read entire sentences written in pinyin.
Because pinyin was implemented by the Russians to teach Chinese to people who use Cyrillic characters. Would make as much sense to call out people who can’t use Katakana.
outhouseperilous@lemmy.dbzer0.com 3 days ago
Ah! But you can skip all that messy biology abd stuff i don’t understand that’s probably not important, abd just think of it as a classical computer running an x86 architecture, and checkmate, liberal my argument owns you now!