I fully agree that if it comes down to “left to right” the problem really needs to be rewritten to be more clear. But I’ve just shown why that “rule” is a common part of these meme problems because it is so weird and quite esoteric.
Comment on A fake Facebook event disguised as a math problem has been one of its top posts for 6 months
barsoap@lemm.ee 1 month agoIt’s ambiguous which one of these is correct. Hence the best method we have for “correct” is left to right.
The solution accepted anywhere but in the US school system is “Bloody use parenthesis, then”, as well as “Why is there more than one division in this formula why didn’t you re-arrange everything to be less confusing” up to “50 Hertz, in base units, are 50s^-1^”.
HereIAm@lemmy.world 1 month ago
SmartmanApps@programming.dev 4 days ago
I fully agree that if it comes down to “left to right”
It never does
But I’ve just shown why that “rule” is a common part
No you didn’t. You showed you didn’t understand the rules. Doing addition first for 10-1+1 is 10+1-1, not 10-(1+1). It literally means add all positive numbers together first, which are +10 and +1, as per Maths textbooks…
Note in the above simplification of the coefficients we have 6-11+5-7+2=6+5+2-11-7=13-18=-5, and not, as you claim 6-(11+5)-(7+2)=6-16-9=-19
because it is so weird and quite esoteric
It’s a convention, not a rule, and as such can be completely ignored by those who understand the rules. See literal textbook example
HereIAm@lemmy.world 4 days ago
I know it’s not a rule, hence why I put it in quotation marks. I noted in another comment that, yes, the proper way is to group it as 1+(-2)+3 and you can do it in any order. What I meant with ““rule”” is the meme questions pray on people not understanding/remembering what the actual rules are or why “left to right” conventions exist.
SmartmanApps@programming.dev 3 days ago
the proper way is to group it as 1+(-2)+3
No it isn’t.
you can do it in any order
You can do it in any order anyway
left to right 1-2+3=-1+3=2
addition first 1+3-2=4-2=2
subtraction first -2+1+3=-1+3=2
right to left 3-2+1=1+1=2
What I meant with ““rule”” is the meme questions pray on people not understanding/remembering what the actual rules are
And you showed that you were one of them. Every answer you got other than 4 was wrong, because you didn’t understand the rules. spoiler alert: doing it in different orders never means add brackets to it. Addition first for 10-1+1 is 10+1-1, not 10-(1+1). See previous textbook example
SmartmanApps@programming.dev 3 weeks ago
No, the solution is learn the rules of Maths. You can find them in Maths textbooks.
Yes we do, and it’s what we teach students to do.