Copyleft “fanfics” are what we call the entire SCP universe. CC-BY-SA is just like the GPL. Notice it’s not CC-BY-SA-NC (NonCommercial). Labor, even if it’s “mods” or “fanfics” is still labor. What, suddenly your work grew in value because it was based off of a different license agreement? The hard work didn’t change, yet it suddenly legitimately grew in value?
If i ever made a game, im making sure everything is released cc by sa and a FLOSS software license for the source code. Because fuck the mentality that says your work isn’t valuable simply because I didn’t give you a license to “my stuff”
captainlezbian@lemmy.world 5 days ago
Labor is labor, and copyleft is great. Hell copyright has massive issues. But also if youre going to participate in amateur labor where it would be illegal to profit, something wonderful and fulfilling for many people, then you don’t get mad when you don’t get paid. If you decide you’d like to make it something you get compensated for you can file the serial numbers off as has become a common practice for fanfic writers who achieve a certain level of popularity.
But also, the exchange of money changes the nature of labor. Labor done out of love and a desire to create and act and give to one’s community is deeply human and quite satisfying and it’s why amateur communities develop culture of amateurism. And it’s why many people who don’t want to do these things for a living choose to do them for a hobby
dreadbeef@lemmy.dbzer0.com 5 days ago
Selling a game based off of the hard work of a game engine: good
Selling a mod based off of the hard work of intellectual property: bad
Is that too reductive?
captainlezbian@lemmy.world 5 days ago
Being paid to compete in professional sports vs being paid to compete in intramural sports. It’s the same industry is it not?
dreadbeef@lemmy.dbzer0.com 5 days ago
What’s wrong with accepting payment for playing a sport? I really don’t see a problem of somebody trying to earn a living by doing that