Exactly the same time you did.

I started gaming less consistently so paying for Xbox live didn’t make sense for me anymore. I switched to mainly playing my PS3 because the online was free.

When Sony announced they were charging for online play, I bought a gaming PC instead of an Xbox One or PS4. At that point, the line between console and PC barely existed anymore. I already pay for internet, no reason I should have to pay again just to use it for gaming.