Comment on How do you keep up?
sugar_in_your_tea@sh.itjust.works 1 month agoWatchtower
Glad it works for you.
Automatic updates of software with potential breaking changes scares me. I’m not familiar with watchtower, since I don’t use it or anything like it, but I have several services that I don’t use very often, but would suck if they silently stopped working properly.
When I think of a service, I think of something like Nextcloud, Immich, etc, even if they consist of multiple containers. For example, I have a separate containers for libre office online and Nextcloud, but I upgrade them together. I don’t want automated upgrades of either because I never know if future builds will be compatible. So I go update things when I remember, but I make sure everything works after.
That said, it seems watchtower can be used to merely notify, so maybe I’ll use it for that. I certainly want to be around for any automatic updates though.
Fedegenerate@lemmynsfw.com 1 month ago
It’s Watchtower that I had problems with because of what you described. Watchtower will drop your microservice, say a database to update it and then not reset the things that are dependent on it. It can be great just not in the ham fisted way I used it.
Uptime Kuma can alert you when a service goes down. I am constantly in my Homarr homepage that tells me if it can’t ping a service, then I go investigating.
I get that it’s scary, and after my Watchtower trauma I was hesitant to go automatic too. But, I’m managing 5 machines now, and scaling by getting more so I have to think about scale.
Pika@sh.itjust.works 1 month ago
I don’t use Watchtower myself for the same reasons described, but I was under the understanding if you had a container as a dependency on another container that if you took the dependency down it also took the container down. Is this not actually true?
Fedegenerate@lemmynsfw.com 1 month ago
I am not the person to be asking, I am no docker expert. It’s is my understanding depends_on: defines starting order. Once a service is started, it’s started. If it has an internal check for “healthy” I believe watchtower will restart unhealthy containers.
This is blind leading the blind though, I would check the documentation if using watchtower. We should both go read the “depends on” documents as we both use it.
Pika@sh.itjust.works 1 month ago
Strangely it sounds like that’s correct. I was under the understanding that depends_on cared about it past start as well but it does not. It doesn’t look like there’s a native way of turning containers that are depending on one another when you turn the dependency off. It looks like the current recommended way of doing it is either with a Docker compose file (which doesn’t help if the process crashed), or having a third party script on the host monitor is the dependencies and if one is considered offline, it turns the dependees off.