Comment

Comment on Reddit is Dead. Lemmy is Dead. Everything is Dead.

arrakark@10291998.xyz ⁨1⁩ ⁨year⁩ ago

Hi. I’m sorry, I didn’t mean it that way. People have put a lot of effort into developing Lemmy as both a software and a community, and it wasn’t my intention to devalue anyone’s efforts or say that it’s a lost cause. I think people should continue using Lemmy. This was just literally my stream of consciousness. I’m more upset that the original Reddit is gone and I wanted to highlight how Lemmy is not a perfect replacement.

source

Sort:hotnew top

april@lemmy.world ⁨1⁩ ⁨year⁩ ago
I think that intro (and the dead lemmy thumbnail) and the long part about reddit is why you got downvoted. People want to hear good things or constructive criticism about their niche platform and are kinda tired of reddit.

Try not to get discouraged about posting. I saw what you meant later in the article, it just came off badly from the intro materials.

source
remotelove@lemmy.ca ⁨1⁩ ⁨year⁩ ago
Lemmy is a perfect replacement for Reddit because it’s not Reddit. The feed was curated and not as organic as the voting system made it seem. As time passed, it became more of an algorithmic engine for dopamine extraction. Sure, I had some great times there, but times change.

Lemmy is not a perfect copy, but it is a healthier replacement in some ways. Separate instances do amplify echo chambers, but, they mildly serve to keep different groups separated. Some personality types are just not compatible and that is OK. We still have common spaces and can still be civil, mostly.

For now, there isn’t as much room here for business. Sure, we have plenty of porn but this platform isn’t as easy to exploit for money as Reddit was. No centralized advertising structure is awesome, IMHO. (Some clients still leverage ads, but I don’t use them.)

source
- 4Robato@lemmy.world ⁨1⁩ ⁨year⁩ ago
  Why people say seperate instances amplify echo chambers? I can follow any community I want, it might be true that similar people go to similar instances but then you can see the others without noticing what instance they belong. In lemmy you follow communities and not people so I feel this happens even less since everyone comments on any community.
  
  And as a site note I think the internet showed that putting everyone in once place is not always healthy for everyone.
  
  The internet should respect different cultures and not try to homogenize everything.
  
  source
  - remotelove@lemmy.ca ⁨1⁩ ⁨year⁩ ago
    Its probably more accurate for me to say that I think there is a gradient of people between instances. Using politics as an example, and without details, people seem to gravitate to instances where they are with like-minded folk. Combine that with local or global filter preferences, and echo chambers start to form on a per-instance basis. Communities of higher interest will likely be on the users home instance, after all.
    
    But yeah, I am fairly sure most of us browse /all and see content from all over Lemmy. We still mix and mingle, but are still lightly bound by our own filter preferences. See above paragraph.)
    
    (I am not trying to dictate hard rules of behavior, btw. Lemmy is too diverse for anything definitive.)
    
    Personally, I try to only block specific communities and not entire instances. That has seemed to keep my personal feeds fairly open.
    
    source