Comment on Generative AI creates playable version of Doom game with no code
echodot@feddit.uk 2 months agoSo you think a project should be killed immediately at Inception because it’s not immediately perfect? That is a really really weird attitude.
Drusenija@lemmy.world 2 months ago
I’m more taking issue with this quote from the article:
“Researchers behind the project say similar AI models could be used to create games from scratch in the future, just as they create text and images today.”
This doesn’t strike me as something that can create a game from scratch, it’s something that can take an existing game and replicate it without having access to the underlying source code, and use an immense amount of processing power to do it.
Since it seems they’re using generative AI based technology underneath it, they’re effectively building a Doom model. You might be able to spin a Doom clone off from that but I don’t see it as something you could practically throw another game type at.
That being said as I said in a different reply, I was viewing it through the lens of something more product based rather than that of a research project. As a field of research, it’s an interesting topic. But I’m not sure how you connect it to “create games from scratch” if you don’t already have an existing game available to train the model on.
echodot@feddit.uk 2 months ago
Why do you think it needs an existing game to train the model on? They used Doom precisely because it already exists.
The entire point to the research paper was to see if humans could tell the difference between the generated content and the real game, that way they have a measurable metric of how viable this technology is even if only in theory, that means that they have to make something that’s based off a real game.
Obviously the technology isn’t commercially viable yet. But the fact that it looks even remotely like Doom shows that there is promise to the technology.