maltfield

You can pay for signed images from someone else

Can you tell me a bit more about this? Who are the major providers?

We do our pre-releases on CI runners for convenience. GitHub automatically kicks-off a build when we git push.

When it comes time to do a real release, we can just run the job locally on our build machines (this is easier thanks to docker). Because our builds are reproducible, we can just check that the hash matches on our local build and the one from the free GitHub CI runners. That way we don’t have to trust the infrastructure, but we can use it for free & easy iteration before our final release.

Yes, you have to trust someone.

My point is that cryptographic signatures can reduce that risk from having to trust tens of thousands of people to just one person.

That’s a hugely meaningful reduction of risk.

How could monitoring a firewall log protect you from a Publishing Infrastructure Compromise or MITM attack? It would just show the malicious image being downloaded from the expected source…

Because the hash comes from the same source as the image itself.

So if someone compromised the publishing infrastructure (or does a MITM attack), they can trivially maliciously modify the hash as easily as they can maliciously modify the image. It provides zero security to Publishing Infrastructure compromise.

A good historical example of this happening was when monero’s release infrastructure was comprimised once. And here’s a great list of historically relevant cases where this happened:

• github.com/cncf/tag-security/tree/…/compromises

In the case of Monero, the users were able to verify that the cryptographic hash on the release was invalid, and it was fixed very fast. If the user can only check checksums, they have literally no way to detect if the publishing infrastructure or a MITM attack is taking place.

but how do you verify the sources of what you’re fetching?

Is it coming from an unsigned git repo? That seems equally vulnerable

Open-Source Software.

Can I install nix to run inside the free CI runners provided by GitHub, GitLab, and Codeberg?