Police in Fairfax, Ohio respond to a shocking call involving 64-year-old Sheila Tenpenny. Detectives quickly turn their attention to her neighbors: 13-year-old Levi Carte and his twin brother Hunter, both fascinated by true crime and serial killers like Ted Bundy. As the investigation unfolds, a series of clues and unsettling discoveries force officers to question everything they thought they knew about this small town.