TLDR: He does not recommend CalyxOS and gave it a score of 3/10
I Tried CalyxOS For 3 Months (So You Don't Have To)
Submitted 3 months ago by TuxEnthusiast@sopuli.xyz to privacyguides@lemmy.one
Submitted 3 months ago by TuxEnthusiast@sopuli.xyz to privacyguides@lemmy.one
TLDR: He does not recommend CalyxOS and gave it a score of 3/10
deadcade@lemmy.deadca.de 3 months ago
This person does not understand open source or Android whatsoever. They talk a decent bit about “default installed apps”, without properly understanding what most of them even are. They complain about some apps “being out of date” when installing CalyxOS, calling it “concerning” that they’re not on the latest version out of the box, as if they couldn’t update the apps themselves. The whole “review” feels more like an iPhone user trying to switch to Android for the first time, being confused because it’s different, and complaining about it because they don’t understand it.
The main benefits of CalyxOS lie under the hood. It’s built to be more secure out of the box, and doesn’t connect everywhere without consent like most other Android ROMs. If you’re fine with the privacy and security of using something like LineageOS, CalyxOS doesn’t have much extra to offer.
paradox2011@lemmy.ml 3 months ago
Thanks for the TL;DR, I figured it would be a uneducated take, you saved me the time of watching it 🫡
Onyx376@lemmy.ml 3 months ago
It’s worth watching, yes. To understand the purpose of CalyxOS, you must understand the purpose of the project, of course. We can’t simply say that it’s a terrible Custom ROM for privacy, as he did. It was quite wrong and in bad faith to say that a project that, yes, is much better than using a Stock ROM, however, the fact that he compared it to other Custom ROMs that also claim to focus on privacy and showed that CalyxOS doesn’t differ much from them is completely valid and truly a fact. DivestOS, with only one developer at the helm, was much more hardened than it. Which makes one wonder why CalyxOS, with an entire team behind it, doesn’t follow the same example. It really is disappointing. Want to prove it? Check out the website (eylenburg.github.io/android_comparison.htm) he shows in the video and see for yourself.
chaoticnumber@lemmy.dbzer0.com 3 months ago
Ah yes, the faux techies. This happens for alot to the technical niches. Wouldn’t pay it any mind. Downvote and move on.
LWD@lemm.ee 3 months ago
Seeing the perspective of somebody who’s not particularly well versed in Android forks is interesting, though.
I found the part around 2:45 to be interesting, where the YouTuber says the thought of the OS getting compromised was scary. This is a sort of privacy paradox where Calyx looks worse than other, less honest, alternatives.
Could a rouge employee compromise Calyx? I guess, but Calyx has the best possible setup to avoid it. And Android itself is basically compromised by default, which should be far more concerning. The biggest reason people aren’t concerned is because Google understands PR, and they know how to spin things in the most positive light possible.