So I’m reading One Hundred Years of Solitude in Spanish (very very slowly and while looking up every third word, I’ve read it in English once or twice) and…like…almost this entire book is exposition. It’s like, pages of exposition leading up to a quick funny joke, and then more pages of exposition.
I’m not complaining. I love it. Márquez is a beautiful, deep, soulful, hilarious writer. He says he wrote this book the way his grandparents would tell him stories. But if I had written this book today, and I brought it to a writing class, or sent it to a literary agent or editor, it’s almost guaranteed that they would just reject this book. “Too much exposition,” they would say. “Needs a total rewrite.” Even though this book is thoroughly entertaining on every page (aside from the incest) and the book itself was a massive hit.
Amusingly, KSR has an article about this. I haven’t finished reading the article. I like KSR but I think he’s overrated and also a lib. I have never been able to finish his books because, well, there’s too much exposition. The exposition derails his stories. His ideas are interesting, but (sounding like your annoying high school writing teacher here), he should work them into action and character, rather than stopping the story to explain them to us.
“Show, don’t tell” is also literal CIA shit. It comes from the Iowa Writers’ Workshop, which was and probably still is run by the CIA. Western literature after 1945 just doesn’t hold a candle to what came before because after 1945 the CIA / OSS gained almost total control over the media. Show your protagonists overcoming challenges but never, ever mention that these challenges are due to capitalism. Popular novels written before 1945 often have shitloads of exposition, and these novels are still read and enjoyed today. Moby Dick is basically, like, half encyclopedia, half novel, and it truly is the best American novel ever written. Poe, easily one of the best American writers (and, like Melville, died a virtual unknown and was only revived later by the French), has stories filled with exposition. Same for Lovecraft.
Exposition or info-dumping is also somewhat permitted in SFF because these stories take place in worlds that are difficult to understand without some sort of explanation. (My new issue with magic is that it’s…impossible and violates conservation of energy. Seeing food just pop out of nowhere in Harry Potter and I’m just like…so labor and thermodynamic work doesn’t exist in this universe? I am the fun police, you are not allowed to have fun. And I only saw this in a youtube clip that was complaining about Harry Potter, by the way. I am not a potthead.)
But the new theory I’m working on is that modern SFF arose specifically in response to anti-colonial uprisings, especially the 1857 Indian “Mutiny.” The British reading public began to sense that the empire was on its way out, they couldn’t possibly hold off their colonial / imperial subjects forever, so they retreated into imaginary fantasy realms where white magical wizards and elves would defeat their enemies, the dark hordes of orcs and demons. So exposition is permitted.
Science fiction is hardly better. People rightfully hate the TNG “planet black people” episode, but that episode just lays bare what science fiction is about: using magical technology (rather than just magic) to keep the racist empire going. Gene Roddenberry conceived of Star Trek as his “wagon train to the stars”—it’s basically cowboys and indians (forgive the racist term) but with spaceships. Space is the final frontier, and these are the voyages of the USS (United States Ship) Capitalist Enterprise. And the “indians” wear alien costumes in Star Trek, except in planet black people, no differently from the Maori actors wearing orc costumes in The Lord of the Rings movies.
This gets to me because I’m suuuuuper sensitive about being accused of having too much exposition in my own stories and I work really hard to eliminate it as much as possible because agents and editors just will not publish books with exposition. It’s my own insecurity talking, even though exposition is a fundamental part of any story. I also have these expository brainworms and will frequently get bored if someone else’s story has too much exposition, although this is not the case in One Hundred Years of Solitude because Márquez’s writing is that good.