Fiona Apple – When The Pawn… (1999, US)
As randomly chosen via Fedi survey,[1] our next spotlight is on number 588 on The List, submitted by Canine.
I’ve had this spotlight in the queue for a while but have had trouble deciding what to include in it, because it seems like literally all anyone mentions about this album is its title, in all its 90-word, 444-character glory. I thought about attempting to write the spotlight without mentioning the title at all, but that’s just silly. Fiona Apple wrote the poem and chose to use it as the album title for a reason – essentially as a reaction to the media et al. acting like shitheads due to her being a woman in the spotlight and all – and the haters win if we pretend she didn’t. But, also, it’s just the title. What about the music?
…Well, to be honest, I can’t seem to connect with the music itself. I think I’ve given this album about three tries in the last couple months and it just doesn’t seem to stick. I don’t even know why, just not my thing I think, or it’s not the right time for me. That doesn’t mean you shouldn’t give this album a spin. You should, I trust these 1001OA contributors. At the very least, knowing the shit Apple had to go through after her first album Tidal (1996) – when she was still just a teenager at at that! – I am very glad she did not give up. Also, I am looking forward to the other Apple album we have on The List, Fetch The Bolt Cutters (2020), as it’s quite possible that one will click and will possibly make this one sound a bit different – so stay tuned to see if I change my, uh, tune.
But if you need a bit of extra nudging for this one here and now (and/or want some Apple-adjacent suggestions for your playlist): what if I told you that there’s a direct line from Elliott Smith to David Bowie through this album?
Okay, check it:
- Elliott Smith works with Jon Brion on his masterpiece, XO (recorded 1997-98, released August 1998), namely as a musician on “Waltz #1”, “Bottle Up and Explode!”, and “Everybody Care, Everybody Understands”.
- Around the same time/just after, Brion recruits session drummer Matt Chamberlain (who had just recently joined Tori Amos’ retinue, beginning with From the Choirgirl Hotel [1998]) for When The Pawn...
- …because Brion is the producer and other main musician alongside Apple on When The Pawn… (recorded 1998-99, released November 1999). Also around the same time, Brion writes the score for P.T. Anderson’s film Magnolia (released December 1999) (and produces the soundtrack that consists primarily of songs by Aimee Mann, Brion’s ex). Why does that matter? Because during this period Anderson is dating Apple, and Anderson produces the music videos for When The Pawn...[2]
- Fast forward a couple years, Chamberlain is hired by David Bowie as the drummer/percussionist for Heathen (2002), and also appears on a couple tracks on Reality (2003) including my favourite, “Bring Me The Disco King”.
What if these prolific session musicians/producers act somewhat like pollinating bees, bringing pieces of the artists they’ve worked with into their work with other artists? Or are the proverbial butterfly that flaps its wings and changes the world? E.g., what if, what if, the king the pawn in Apple’s poem/title is thinking like becomes Bowie’s disco king? Or what if there’s some other small musical piece of Apple – or Amos or Mann – hidden in Bowie? Or what if without Elliott Smith and XO we wouldn’t have Heathen, at least not as we know it, and in large part thanks to this moment in Fiona Apple’s history? I’m stretching, I know…but maybe…
You know, maybe I’ll give this album another try. Also, is it Bowie January yet?
Anyway, here’s the title:
When the pawn hits the conflicts he thinks like a king
What he knows throws the blows when he goes to the fight
And he’ll win the whole thing ‘fore he enters the ring
There’s no body to batter when your mind is your might
So when you go solo, you hold your own hand
And remember that depth is the greatest of heights
And if you know where you stand, then you know where to land
And if you fall it won’t matter, cuz you’ll know that you’re right
- The survey choices that led to this spotlight were: “War is all around us”, “My mind says prepare to fight”, “So if I gotta die”, and “I’m gonna listen to my body tonight” (following a survey that had “I was dreaming when I wrote this”/”So sue me if I go too fast”/”Life is just a party”/”And parties weren’t mean to last”). The last option was the winning selection, so the survey result was translated as picking an album in The List that contains a word in the phrase – in this case, “body”. ↩︎
- Also around the same time-ish but probably after When The Pawn… is done (the Internet differs on whether this was in 1999 or 2000), Anderson directs the pilot episode of Brion’s “The Jon Brion Show” with Elliott Smith as a guest; Apple is in the audience for the taping. ↩︎
1001otheralbums.com@1001otheralbums.com