The sky over Plattsmouth went dark on a June afternoon in 1875 and stayed dark for five days. Dr. Albert L. Child stood under it with instruments. Child was the town physician and a volunteer weather observer for the Army Signal Service, a man in the habit of measuring things, and the swarm passing over his station gave him a problem he could work. The insects came without pause, hour after hour, a column of wings moving on the wind, and by his reading of the instruments the mass of them stood a mile high. He clocked the speed of the passage, wired the towns down the line for their own reports, and multiplied what he had. His arithmetic gave a single living body about 110 miles wide and some 1,800 miles long. The area came to 198,000 square miles, larger than California, and the figure entered the scientific record as the largest measurement ever made of one aggregation of animals. It still holds that rank.

Image

Entomologists have since converted Child’s geography into bodies. Jeffrey Lockwood, the Wyoming entomologist who wrote the standard history of the species, sets a cautious floor of 3.5 trillion insects in that one swarm. Other reckonings, working from the densities farmers reported on the ground, reach 12.5 trillion, a flying mass of some 27 million tons. Guinness lists the event as the greatest concentration of animals ever recorded. The human population of the earth in 1875 was about 1.3 billion, which means the swarm over the plains carried several thousand locusts for every person then alive. Numbers in the trillions resist comprehension because nothing in ordinary life arrives in that denomination. Settlers underneath the swarm did not need the arithmetic. They could hear it, a rasping that filled the air, and they could feel it hitting the house like hail.

The animal had a name and a narrow home. Benjamin Dann Walsh, the Illinois state entomologist, described the species in 1866 and called it Caloptenus spretus; later workers moved it to the genus Melanoplus, where modern DNA work confirms it belongs. To look at, it was a large, dull grasshopper, an inch and a half of mottled brown, unremarkable on a weed. Its power came from a switch in its biology. Crowding and drought pushed solitary hoppers into a gregarious phase that flew, and flew far. It bred permanently only in a belt of sandy river valleys along the Rocky Mountain front, from Montana north into British territory. The plains were its raiding ground, never its nursery. Nobody being raided could see the difference, and the difference decided everything that followed.

The raids crested between 1873 and 1877. Crop losses across the afflicted states and territories are commonly estimated at $200 million in the money of the day. The worst single season was 1874, when the plague ran from the northern territories down through Kansas and western Missouri and whole counties went on relief. The locusts took the wheat and the corn first, then turned to whatever remained: onions, turnips, the wool on living sheep, leather harness, wooden tool handles, fence posts, the quilts and blankets women spread over the gardens. A saying on the plains held that the hoppers ate everything but the mortgage. Families who had proved up homesteads walked away from them with nothing left to defend. Relief committees in the eastern cities raised money and shipped seed back west. Laura Ingalls Wilder, who lived through the visitations of 1874 and 1875 in Minnesota, fixed the experience in On the Banks of Plum Creek, where the descending swarm darkens the sun and the cloud, in her sentence, “was hailing grasshoppers.” The book is a novel, and its grasshoppers behave the way the records say they behaved.

Nebraska answered with a statute. The Legislature passed the Grasshopper Act in the winter of 1877, and the governor signed it on February 23. The law declared the locust a “public enemy,” the legal rank a government reserves for hostile powers, and then it conscripted an army. Every able-bodied man in the state between sixteen and sixty owed two days of labor destroying grasshoppers at hatching time, whenever the local road overseer called him out. A man who refused paid a ten-dollar fine, at a time when ten dollars might run to half a month’s wages for a hired hand. Missouri took the market road instead, posting a bounty of a dollar a bushel in March that stepped down through spring to a dime in June. Either law, read for its logic, delivers the same message. The state had declared war on an insect, and it expected its citizens to fight.

Washington moved in the same season. An act of Congress in March 1877 created the United States Entomological Commission with an appropriation of $18,000, attached to Ferdinand V. Hayden’s Geological and Geographical Survey of the Territories. That was real money for science in 1877, and Congress spent it on a grasshopper. The three commissioners were the leading economic entomologists of their day: Charles Valentine Riley as chief, Alpheus Spring Packard as secretary, Cyrus Thomas as disbursing agent. Riley and Thomas had lobbied the commission into existence, and Congress handed them the enemy they had asked for. Their first annual report, published in 1878, ran to 772 pages and concerned one insect. Laid beside the Nebraska session laws, the two documents rhyme. One government had outlawed the locust. The other had built an institution to study it. Both treated Melanoplus spretus as a permanent feature of continental life, an enemy the country would have to fight season after season, for as long as anyone could see.

The reports are almost entirely concerned with killing. The commissioners rode the afflicted counties through the plague years, counted egg beds, timed hatchings, and drew maps that separated the permanent breeding zone in the mountains from the invaded territory on the plains. Riley judged that one swarm’s footprint on the ground was “equal to the combined areas of” eleven eastern states, and he listed them by name, Connecticut through Vermont. The commission tested the weapons of the hour and reported on each: sheet-metal hopperdozers dragged across fields and smeared with coal tar, fire, deep fall plowing to expose the egg pods, ditches lined with hopper pans. They were good reports, careful and empirical, the best field entomology the country could buy. Nowhere in those 772 pages does anyone propose a census of the animal itself. The reports measure damage in acres and dollars. The locust appears as weather, as an enemy force, as a condition of life on the plains. It never appears as a population that could end.

The raids thinned and then stopped. Swarms still came in 1878 and 1879, weaker each season, and by the middle 1880s the locust had withdrawn from the plains altogether. Farmers took some of the credit. They had switched to winter wheat, which matured before the migrants arrived, and planted alfalfa, which young hoppers would not eat. Plowing went on season after season, and every plowed acre was closed to egg laying. The decisive work, though, happened far from the wheat fields, in the sandy stream bottoms of the Rockies where the species lived from year to year. Settlers were breaking those valleys to the plow, running irrigation ditches through them, and grazing cattle across them. The nursery was being remodeled into farms and pasture, and nobody sounded an alarm, because nobody had understood that the nursery mattered.

Extinction entered the written record through collectors’ notebooks. James Fletcher, the Dominion entomologist, took a male and a female in Manitoba in July 1901. Norman Criddle, a twenty-seven-year-old student of entomology, found another pair in his father’s garden near Treesbank, Manitoba, on July 19, 1902. He wrote the date and the place on the labels, the way a collector does, and the pair went into a drawer. Montana’s first state entomologist wrote the species’ obituary without knowing it: his 1903 report allowed that the Rocky Mountain locust, “if present in the state at all[,] is very rare.” Morgan Hebard took three specimens in Colorado in August 1904 and remarked in print on how difficult they had been to find. No confirmed living specimen has turned up since. The International Union for Conservation of Nature made the extinction official in 2014, a hundred and twelve years after Criddle walked his father’s garden.

Lockwood spent years chasing the disappearance. The answer he published with L. D. DeBrey in 1990 is ecological and unglamorous. The locust’s recovery after every raid depended on a few hundred square miles of permanent breeding ground in the mountain river valleys, and those were precisely the acres the new agriculture wanted: sheltered, watered, level, rich. Plows broke the egg beds. Irrigation drowned them. Cattle trampled the bare sand the females needed for laying. Lockwood’s account leaves room for accomplices. The buffalo were gone from the valleys by then, and the new farms put out the fires that had kept the breeding ground open and bare. The locust never had to be hunted down across the plains, the way Nebraska’s statute imagined. It only had to be evicted from a nursery nobody was watching. Genetic work published in 2004, on DNA recovered from museum specimens and glacier ice, confirmed that spretus was a real and distinct species, and it found no sign of the inbreeding collapse that a sick-population theory would require. The animal was not dying of anything. Its home was being plowed under.

The passenger pigeon is the parallel everyone reaches for, and it holds. Both were North American species that existed in the trillions or billions, both concentrated to breed, and both collapsed from uncountable to absent within a human generation. Their numbers were protection and weakness at once; each species survived as a mass, and when the mass broke, nothing remained. One casualty is chained to the locust’s fate. The Eskimo curlew fed on spretus during its spring migration, and the bird’s decline tracked the insect’s disappearance.

These two records, set side by side, tell on their makers. The most numerous animal on the continent was measured once, by a small-town doctor with a telegraph key, and the measurement was meteorology: speed, width, duration. After that, nobody counted. Nebraska drafted its citizens and fined the ones who refused to kill. The commission counted damage in dollars and mapped the enemy’s range. Population, in the sense a field biologist would mean today, does not occur in either record. Nobody knew how many locusts there were when there were trillions, so nobody could say when the number became millions, then thousands, then two insects in a Manitoba garden. It vanished inside the filing system that had been built to fight it.

I grew up in Nebraska, where the grasshopper years survive as folklore: the darkened sky, the crunch underfoot, the tar smeared on sheet metal. The Grasshopper Act always got a laugh in the telling, the picture of the Legislature drafting its able-bodied men for two days of war against bugs. That joke has since curdled on me. The law was not foolish. It was proportionate, a rational conscription against a measurable enemy, and the ten-dollar fine was serious money seriously meant. What failed was the bookkeeping. A government can declare an animal a public enemy, appropriate money to study it, and pass laws to destroy it, and still never learn the one number that would have said what was happening. The locust was counted once as a weather event and fought for years as an invader. It was never counted as a species, and by the time anyone wanted that count, the species was gone.

The record closes on ice. In the high cirques of the Rockies, at Grasshopper Glacier in Montana and Knife Point Glacier in Wyoming, tons of locusts lie frozen where they fell centuries ago, wings and legs mummified in the blue ice. Frozen bodies several hundred years old have been cut from the Wind River ice in Wyoming, whole locusts out of swarms older than the republic. The glaciers kept the only census anyone will ever have of Melanoplus spretus, and they kept it by accident. Criddle’s two specimens from the Treesbank garden sit pinned in a Canadian collection. Child’s number sits in the commission’s first report, unrepeated to this day. Between the doctor’s telegraph and the student’s pins there are twenty-seven years, and in that span the commonest animal in North America went from a sky that moved to a rare insect to a name in a statute nobody enforces. Nebraska still has its session laws. The glaciers are melting. The count will not improve.